News
Inside Call me Back SNEAK PEEK: Between Mamdani and Tucker, Are Jews Getting Squeezed? - with Jonah Goldberg
In this sneak peek episode of 'Inside Call Me Back,' Jonah Goldberg discusses the implications of Zoran Mamdani's election as New York City's mayor, particularly regarding rising a...
Inside Call me Back SNEAK PEEK: Between Mamdani and Tucker, Are Jews Getting Squeezed? - with Jonah Goldberg
News •
0:00 / 0:00
Interactive Transcript
spk_0
You are listening to an art media podcast.
spk_0
The Bill of Rights is a classical liberal document.
spk_0
Once you reject that and you embrace illiberalism, then the differences between the far right
spk_0
and the far left kind of disappear.
spk_0
The illiberal left and the illiberal right, they all believe in speech codes, they all
spk_0
believe in punishing your enemies, they all believe in identity politics.
spk_0
So there are a lot of things where it's really about power.
spk_0
And so like Zora Mondami represents a kind of left-wing, identitarian,
spk_0
stateism, and so do a lot of these Tucker Carlson wannabe guys who just basically want to
spk_0
use the government to reward our team and punish your enemies.
spk_0
And so there, the horseshoe theory stuff actually holds.
spk_0
Once you let go of the classically liberal dogma of that our rights come from God, not from
spk_0
government.
spk_0
We are citizens not subjects that the fruits of our labor belong to us.
spk_0
Once you give up that stuff, it's really just two different teams of illiberals.
spk_0
It's 2pm on Friday, November 7th here in New York City.
spk_0
It's 9pm on Friday, November 7th in Israel, whether you are here or there, Shabbat Shalom.
spk_0
On Monday, Hamas returned three deceased hostages to Israel.
spk_0
They are Asaf Hamami, Azdanyal, and Omar Nutra, who, Omar also is an American citizen.
spk_0
On Wednesday, deceased hostage Itay Khan was also returned to Israel.
spk_0
And on Thursday, deceased hostage Joseph Loi-Tu Mollel, a Tanzanian national, was also
spk_0
returned.
spk_0
As of now, there are six deceased hostages still in Gaza.
spk_0
One of these hostages is Hadar Golden, who was killed and abducted by Hamas in 2014.
spk_0
Israel has assessed that the body of Hadar is trapped in an area of Rafa that is now on
spk_0
the Israeli controlled side of the yellow line that was established by the recent cease
spk_0
fire deal.
spk_0
In that same area, there are believed to be 150 Hamas operatives trapped in a tunnel
spk_0
and unable to access the Hamas controlled part of the Gaza Strip.
spk_0
There is also an internal scandal unfolding in Israel that has to do with the former chief
spk_0
attorney of the IDF, Yifat Tomeriyarushaumi, who admitted last week to having approved
spk_0
the leak of footage that allegedly showed Israeli operatives at the state Tehran detention
spk_0
facility abusing a Gaza detainee.
spk_0
Tomeriyarushaumi was arrested Sunday night on suspicion of trying to obstruct the investigation
spk_0
into her case.
spk_0
Tomeriyarushaumi's phone, which was missing, was reportedly found in the sea on Thursday
spk_0
and is currently being examined by police investigators.
spk_0
She was released to house arrests Friday morning, one of our ArchMedia podcasts for
spk_0
Heaven's Sake, co-hosted by Danielle Hartman and Yossi Klein-Helevie, delved into this
spk_0
saga and their most recent episode.
spk_0
So I highly recommend anyone who is interested in learning more to listen to that episode
spk_0
of For Heaven's Sake.
spk_0
In other news, on Wednesday, Turkey's intelligence agency chief met with the leader of Hamas's
spk_0
negotiating team, Khalil Alhaya, to discuss how Hamas should approach the continued implementation
spk_0
of Trump's cease fire deal.
spk_0
Also on Thursday, Israel launched a wave of strikes on Hezbollah targets in Lebanon,
spk_0
issuing evacuation warnings for five different areas.
spk_0
Prime Minister Netanyahu convened his security cabinet just a couple of hours ago to discuss
spk_0
the path forward both in Gaza and in Lebanon.
spk_0
Now onto today's episode.
spk_0
Late Tuesday night, Democratic candidate Zoran Mamdani was elected mayor of New York City,
spk_0
home to the largest number of Jews outside of Israel.
spk_0
Mamdani received around 50% of the vote while his leading opponent, former governor Andrew
spk_0
Cuomo, got 41% of the vote.
spk_0
Mamdani is a 34 year old self-proclaimed Democratic Socialist and a self-proclaimed anti-Israel
spk_0
activist.
spk_0
So on the left, Mamdani's mayoral victory signaled a legitimization of anti-Semitism and
spk_0
anti-Zionism.
spk_0
But at the same time, we are also seeing a crack up on the right over anti-Semitism,
spk_0
as some podcasters with very large audiences have been saying some incendiary things about
spk_0
Israel and the Jews.
spk_0
The edges, both the left and the right, seem to be coalescing around anti-Jewish conspiracy
spk_0
theories, blood libels, and scapegoating.
spk_0
Have the far left and the far right found a common enemy?
spk_0
Are we seeing the horseshoe theory coming to life in the most ghoulish way?
spk_0
And does the fringe of either the left or the right threaten to go mainstream on either the center
spk_0
left or the center right?
spk_0
Yesterday, we published a special members only inside Call Me Back episode.
spk_0
Today, we are unlocking a good chunk of that episode to our free feed,
spk_0
to the main Call Me Back feed because of the importance of this conversation.
spk_0
If you do find it interesting, you might want to follow the link in the show notes and
spk_0
subscribe to Inside Call Me Back where you can hear the entirety of the conversation.
spk_0
And I should also mention that this episode was recorded well before Shabbat,
spk_0
and it's on an auto-program release time, so it's being released on Saturday,
spk_0
but no human being is actually pressing a button and releasing it,
spk_0
and everyone should listen to it whenever they feel comfortable and appropriate doing so.
spk_0
Our guest today is Jonah Goldberg. Jonah is the editor-in-chief and co-founder of the Dispatch,
spk_0
which is a very important publication. I highly recommend it. I subscribe to it. I especially
spk_0
enjoy their Morning Newsletter, which I start with every day, one of the best coming out of Washington.
spk_0
He's also the author of multiple books that examine political history and the history of conservative
spk_0
ideas, including Suicide of the West, and also liberal fascism. Jonah is also the host of the
spk_0
indispensable podcast called The Remnant. If you don't already listen to it, subscribe. We'll
spk_0
link to that as well on the show notes. So Jonah, first, welcome to Call Me Back. It's great to be here.
spk_0
So Jonah, I got to start by asking you. Suicide of the West came out in 2018, and I guess after
spk_0
this past seven to ten days, exactly what stage of the suicide are we in right now?
spk_0
Well, not to dodge the question, but I think part of the problem is that the suicide of which I speak
spk_0
is always on offer, right? Ronald Reagan said, we're not born with a love for liberty in our blood.
spk_0
Every generation is threatened because it only takes one generation to lose your commitment to
spk_0
these things. And so it's an ongoing process where you have to sort of remind people to have
spk_0
some gratitude for what a wonderful country this is and for the principles and values that it was
spk_0
built on. And we're doing a really bad job of that right now. Let me put it this way. And we're
spk_0
going to get into a lot of this stuff. Some of the things Ben Shapiro has been saying about the
spk_0
neo-Nazi stuff on the right. I welcome it. I celebrate it. He's right. It's good that he's doing it.
spk_0
But there were some of us who were saying this stuff will not end well 10 years ago.
spk_0
I was the subject, like the ADL did a study of the-
spk_0
They're in the lead up to 2016, right? In the lead up to the presidential election.
spk_0
Yeah. I came in like six or eighth on that list and Ben came in first or second. And I was
spk_0
getting into arguments when these guys 10 years ago saying you cannot have these people as allies
spk_0
in your coalition. You can't have them in your tent. You're inviting the scorpion to sting you.
spk_0
And so there's a certain amount of, you know, just it's very hard to resist the itoji
spk_0
shows at a moment like this. But I told people so. You know, it's worth actually underlining this
spk_0
point. So you are from our listeners who don't know you. You are a conservative. You would
spk_0
identify as a conservative. You came of age with conservative leaders like Ronald Reagan and
spk_0
Phil Graham, your intellectual heroes among them were Bill Buckley who you worked for in national
spk_0
reviews. So when I say you're a conservative, that's not in the mega sense. This is the
spk_0
conservatism you came of age with. And you have also, as you said, been the target of anti-Semitism
spk_0
coming from all sides, I guess, of the political spectrum. Yeah. Most of my life was from the left
spk_0
until the last 10 years. Yeah. Okay. I want to start with your a little bit of your origin story here
spk_0
because it's very relevant to the politics we're dealing with right now in New York City. You
spk_0
are from New York City. Yeah. Anyone who knows you knows that, you know, you're constantly making
spk_0
references to New York City and growing up in New York City. So New York City played a meaningful
spk_0
part in your life formative years. And this city has now elected a self-described socialist and
spk_0
anti-signist mayor. Now we can get into what that means because I know you're skeptical that it
spk_0
means what we all think it means. But let's just take Zorn Maldonny at his own words, a socialist
spk_0
and anti-signist mayor. Just started for New York Jews, the New York Jewish community. What do you
spk_0
think his election means or what should it mean? It's not great, Bob, because I think this is one of
spk_0
the few places I can say this with the maximum impact to explain to people how long I've been doing
spk_0
conservative stuff and how much I grew up in this stuff. You know, when I first met Papi Canon
spk_0
at my brisk. So I've been doing this for a while, right? I grew up in this. Was it national
spk_0
review for 20 years? No, I just want to be clear. You're not suggesting that Papi Canon was performing
spk_0
the brisk. He was not the loyal. He was not the loyal. He was a guest. He was a guest at the brisk.
spk_0
But for our listeners, that gives you a sense of how long Jonah has been swimming in conservative
spk_0
political waters. And when he was introduced to my dad for the first time by my brother's godfather,
spk_0
this guy Victor Lasky, who was a big muck-raking conservative journalist of the 1960s,
spk_0
and he introduced Pat to my dad and he said, Sid, I want you to meet Papi Canon. He is a terrific
spk_0
red-baiter. And he meant it totally as a compliment. My dad received it as a compliment. So that's
spk_0
like the milieu I grew up in. So there's a literary critic Wayne Booth who has this line that I'm
spk_0
going to butcher a little bit. But it goes something like this. Redric is the art of figuring out what
spk_0
men believe they ought to believe. It sets the rhetorical ideal, the parameters, the over-tune
spk_0
window of what people should believe. Redric is this thing. How we talk in our politics,
spk_0
sets the framework for how we should think about things. And the fact that you've got a guy who
spk_0
has said that every time the NYPD puts its boot on your neck, it was laced by the IDF,
spk_0
when you have a guy who has got a rhetorical paper trail like that, a reason because he's so
spk_0
young, all of it is recent. It's not great. And I have no objection whatsoever for New York Jews
spk_0
to object and to worry about this. My oldest friend in Washington, Tevi Troy just said a piece in
spk_0
the Wall Street Journal this week about how he wears a Kippa, a Yamaka in New York. And he's now
spk_0
worried that that's not going to be safe for him to do. And Tevi's a very level-headed guy. He's
spk_0
not crazy for feeling that way. So at that level as a cultural thing, part of the problem of our politics
spk_0
these days, particularly with the presidency, is we see candidates more as avatars of a culture war
spk_0
than as actual public servants being hired to fix certain problems and do certain things.
spk_0
And so a big part of Mondami's success was being this transgressive avatar of a certain kind of
spk_0
left-wing politics that seduced a whole bunch of people. And he's very good at it. He's a
spk_0
charismatic guy. He knows how to use social media, smiles all the time. He's very disciplined about
spk_0
how he can dodge certain questions and that kind of thing. And he ran against a weak field,
spk_0
both in the primary and in the general. And he won. And I personally think it's a bad sign for
spk_0
the country. Like I want certain things to just be unacceptable in politics. The sky, Jay Jones,
spk_0
was the attorney general in Rantford, Attorney General in Virginia. He was exposed, sent text
spk_0
messages and phone calls talking about how he wished to see some Republicans, children murdered
spk_0
in front of him. And he got elected. And he got elected. Like I want to live in a country where
spk_0
there are certain things. I'm not, this is not about cancel culture. This is about decency in
spk_0
public life. There are certain things, there are certain rhetorical positions people take that
spk_0
should just make them outside of the realm of acceptable public officials. And I think Cuomo,
spk_0
you know, should have never run either for all the me-to-ish stuff. But with Mondami in particular,
spk_0
it's very troubling. That said, I think some of the catastrophization about it is probably overdone,
spk_0
both on the, oh, he's going to make it a communist, you know, hellhole, or the pogroms will start
spk_0
it dawn. I mean, I think there are people who will take bad inspiration from Mondami and do bad
spk_0
things to Jews. And that's terrible. And then Mondami will have a terrible test for himself,
spk_0
about whether they're actually going to, you know, like punish that kind of stuff. And I hate
spk_0
saying that that's a possibility. But I think it's a possibility. But I don't think it's open
spk_0
season on Jews in New York either. And I don't think Mondami has the ability to seize the means
spk_0
of production in New York City. He's going to have a rough time doing a lot of the things he says he's
spk_0
going to do. But you okay. So the difference between someone like Jay Jones and I'm familiar with
spk_0
it. I didn't follow it as closely as you did. But it seems to me like he got caught saying something
spk_0
that he would not have wanted to advertise. I think the difference with Mamdani is there's no
spk_0
getting caught. In other words, he is broadcast quite proudly his worldview long before October 7th,
spk_0
long before he ran for the state assembly long and when he was a student in college, he was talking
spk_0
about that. And then when he had the opportunity as a citywide candidate and ultimately the nominee
spk_0
of his party or what became his party, the Democrats, he had the opportunity to moderate. And he
spk_0
actually didn't really moderate. I know Jewish leaders who met with him, who tried to meet with him,
spk_0
who I mean, I thought it was foolish. I thought it was naive. They were trying to like an olive
spk_0
branch. We get giving him ways to tone it down. And he didn't tone it down. He was talking about
spk_0
genocide and apartheid state and shutting down the Cornell Technion partnership and shutting down
spk_0
the strategic response group, this unit and the NYPD that deals has dealt with a lot of violent
spk_0
anti-Semitic protests over the last couple of years. He was talking about those issues and about
spk_0
doing those things two weeks ago, not two years ago. And it was a feature of his campaign.
spk_0
It wasn't something that I got caught and I got to now clean it up. I think that's a hugely
spk_0
important distinction. I think you're right. It's the difference between bug and feature.
spk_0
This Jones guy screwed up in private and did something really evil and bad. And he didn't really
spk_0
do a good job apologizing for it. But he didn't campaign on. I'm going to murder my opponent's
spk_0
children. Right? Right. Meanwhile, Mandami is part of the package of who he is. He is a sort of
spk_0
trust-affarian, campus, globalized the intifada kind of guy. And that crap is really hot right now,
spk_0
among a bunch of young people. I don't think if he actually explicitly, the one distinction I would
spk_0
draw is that he didn't run away from it, but he didn't lean into it and campaign on it the way
spk_0
he focused on the affordability thing, which if he basically made his number one campaign promise
spk_0
to arrest BB Netnau if he ever goes to the UN or something, the thing might have played out
spk_0
differently. But in some ways, I feel he's a little bit like a Chi Pong Kong knockoff of Barack
spk_0
Obama. Barack Obama had a lot of crappy stuff that he didn't really distance himself from in his
spk_0
record. His relationships with some really anti-Israel people, but the charisma of it and the
spk_0
the really weird virtue signaling that appeals to people of how transgressive you are to vote for
spk_0
a guy named Zoran Mandami or Barack Hussein, Obama. There's some of that fattish stuff going on there.
spk_0
But I love New York City's Jewish heritage. It's one of the things that makes New York City
spk_0
New York City and there's no really getting around that. It's not just Jews. It's immigrant
spk_0
heritage. It's just huge and great and wonderful and I love all that stuff. At the same time,
spk_0
there's a reason why the East Germans had to build the Berlin Wall to keep people from voting with
spk_0
their feet. You cannot do many of the things that are his heart's desire without losing very wealthy
spk_0
people without losing a lot of Jews without real political consequences. And so I just think he's
spk_0
intellectual lightweight when it comes to actual public policy. And I think the mayor,
spk_0
mayoralty in New York City is not that powerful a position to allow him to do all the things that
spk_0
he wants to do. He needs buy-in from the governor, from the state legislature, from the city council.
spk_0
And much like Barack Obama, Barack Obama was great at giving speeches to adoring crowds.
spk_0
He actually wasn't that great at the nuts and bolts of governing and public policy.
spk_0
And he basically didn't do anything on the domestic agenda after he got Obama care passed
spk_0
precisely because he swung for the fences on one thing and then it cost him Congress.
spk_0
In 2010, the midterms. Yeah, most of his presidency after that was pen and phone as he put it and
spk_0
rhetoric. Okay, let's take a break to hear a word from our sponsor. One of the most enduring
spk_0
strengths of the Jewish people is our instinct to take responsibility for one another. It's a guiding
spk_0
principle of the Jewish communal fund. For more than 50 years, the Jewish communal fund has been a
spk_0
home for Jewish philanthropy, making it easy, impactful, and tax smart to give. Recently, JCF
spk_0
fund holders granted over $1 billion to a wide range of 501C3 charities in a single year.
spk_0
Much of it going to Jewish causes, day school scholarships, and food pantries,
spk_0
emergency aid for Israel and programs fighting anti-semitism here at home.
spk_0
A JCF donor advised fund lets you contribute appreciated assets, take your deduction this year,
spk_0
and direct support when it's needed most, whether that's rebuilding a community in Israel or
spk_0
strengthening Jewish education in New York. When you give through JCF, you're investing in Jewish life.
spk_0
To learn more about opening your fund by December 31st to lock in 2025's tax advantages,
spk_0
follow the link in the show notes or go to JCFNY.org, the Jewish communal fund.
spk_0
We're giving back means building the Jewish future.
spk_0
All right, so we're already seeing Democrats from around the country congratulating
spk_0
Mamdani, celebrating Mamdani while, you know, some pundits are saying Mamdani is the future of the
spk_0
party, which is interesting, by the way, because there were two other big elections in New Jersey and
spk_0
in Virginia, gubernatorial races, where Democrats that are not Mamdani, don't represent Mamdaniism,
spk_0
performed quite well, but all the conversation is about Mamdani. And so now there's this debate,
spk_0
is Mamdani now like the future of the party? Is he effectively a national project? What's your
spk_0
reaction to that? Yeah, so it is really important to point out that on their liquidate to Kool-Ox tour,
spk_0
whatever it was that AOC and Bernie Sanders did, you know, their anti-billionaire thing.
spk_0
Mickey Cheryl, the gubernatorial candidate in New Jersey, did not invite them to come speak.
spk_0
They play really well in New York City and maybe in San Francisco and LA and that kind of stuff,
spk_0
but they did not campaign in purplish states or in swing districts or anything like that.
spk_0
It gets signal boosted by the media, by the national media, because they are much closer to
spk_0
Zoron Nandami than they are to Mickey Cheryl or Abigail Spamberger. And they're great copy, right?
spk_0
That's part of the problem of these times is that responsible politicians who just want to do the
spk_0
important hard-boring work are terrible copy. They're not charismatic, they don't get the headlines,
spk_0
they don't seek the headlines. And meanwhile, the splash of your people get the headlines.
spk_0
If I had my druthers, I would have wanted, even though like if I were in New Jersey or Virginia,
spk_0
I might have voted for the Republicans, I might not have. I don't know, that part isn't a guy anymore.
spk_0
But in terms of what's best for America, what I would have wanted to see is Mondami lose
spk_0
and Jay Jones lose. But these more moderate Democrats win big like they did. And the Democratic
spk_0
Party is setting up itself for a big internal debate. You know, in public choice theory,
spk_0
there's this thing called Baptists and Bootleggers. What it refers to is in dry states
spk_0
during the prohibition era or whatever. The two groups that were most in favor of prohibition were
spk_0
the Baptists who were against drinking on religious reasons. And the bootleggers, because they kept
spk_0
the legal competition away from them and they could charge whatever prices they want on the black
spk_0
market. And so they kind of like there were bootleggers who funded Baptists and wanted to
spk_0
maintain prohibition kind of thing. There is a similar sort of dynamic going on between the GOP
spk_0
and the AOC wing. It helps the GOP if the face of the Democratic Party is Zora Mondami.
spk_0
And it helps the Zora Mondami wing of the Democratic Party if the GOP aims all its fire at them.
spk_0
Because in this climate right now of negative polarization, the more the people you hate, hate you,
spk_0
the better off you are. Right. And that's why Ted Cruz loved and all these guys loved the troll
spk_0
are Donald Trump. They love the troll. The hardcore left because a lot of people love politicians
spk_0
these days for their enemies rather than for what they actually stand for. And it's a sick sort
spk_0
of dynamic, but it's a big part of our politics these days. All right. So I want to actually before
spk_0
move on, I actually want to define what we actually think Mondami really represents ideologically,
spk_0
because it's confusing. You just wrote this column in the LA Times that we'll link to. You basically
spk_0
argued that whether Mondami's a socialist or not, you don't believe this is like a belt. This is
spk_0
not like a way to measure whether or not socialism is in again. And I want to come back to that.
spk_0
But I also want to quote from this piece in the free press by Zineb Rabua. And this piece tries to
spk_0
argue that like what we think Mondami represents is not what it is. And I'm just going to read from it
spk_0
in a lot of hates when I read from pieces. And but I'm just going to do it. I won't read too much.
spk_0
She says, Mamdani in truth draws from a very distinct left wing tradition. Third world is a
spk_0
post-colonial moral project born in the mid 20th century that recasts politics as a global uprising
spk_0
against Western hegemony, his convictions echo the Algerian revolution's core belief that the
spk_0
oppressed occupy histories moral vanguard and their liberation redeems human dignity. And he
spk_0
goes on to say, you know, conservatives trained to debate policies and principles are unprepared
spk_0
for this kind of politics. Wokeism was only the beginning showing that moral language can sustain
spk_0
ideology more effectively than doctrine of policy. Mamdani represents the next stage. He's turned
spk_0
this moral framework into political practice carrying out beyond culture and identifies into economics
spk_0
and foreign affairs. And he basically argues because of the Gaza war because of some other
spk_0
factors Mamdani found this audience at a moment when decolonial rhetoric actually became prominent.
spk_0
We call him a socialist. What this piece is arguing is it's not really socialism. This is actually
spk_0
something new in mainstream American politics. Look, one of the things when I used to be in much
spk_0
better odor on the right, I used to point out to people is that the differences between nationalism
spk_0
and socialism as historical movements are incredibly minor to nonexistent. There's a Marxist tradition
spk_0
that teaches people that nationalism and socialism are opposites. Let's put it this way. Take any
spk_0
speech by Fidel Castro. And every time you hear the word socialist or socialism replace it with
spk_0
nationalist and nationalism or vice versa. It doesn't change the meaning of the paragraphs at all.
spk_0
National liberation, which were all these socialist movements in the third world, the Bandung
spk_0
generation, all of these kinds of things. They were nationalist movements and they were socialist
spk_0
movements. To nationalize health care is to have socialized medicine. And there is this, you know,
spk_0
the third world, France, Fannon kind of tradition of hardcore left wing stuff is a kind of,
spk_0
I don't mean necessarily in the Nazi sense, but it's a nationalist socialist sort of way of seeing
spk_0
the world. And part of that is that there are oppressed peoples and the evil forces of western
spk_0
civilization or the, you know, the pale penis people of patriarchy are out to get them in their
spk_0
enemies. And higher ed is full of this stuff has been for 50 years, right? I mean, whether you
spk_0
want to make it Howard Zinn or, you know, Richard Delgado or whoever you want to point to, it's
spk_0
that kind of identity politics is what they teach in a lot of universities. And
spk_0
Mandami, where did he go? He went to Bowdoin. Bowdoin. Right. I mean, it's a classic example of
spk_0
a rich kid who wants to lean into much like Barack Obama Columbia wants to lean into the sort of
spk_0
frison of radicalism by claiming his sort of third world savior kind of status. And that's what he
spk_0
grew up in. That's the language he speaks. So I agree that that's his comfort zone. This guy's
spk_0
comfort zone is to use this language of sort of this nationalistic identity politics language that
spk_0
uses socialism. I mean, let's remember like the Soviet Union for all it's talk about international
spk_0
communism very quickly. Stalin's talking about the great patriotic war for mother Russia, right? I
spk_0
mean, like the going back and forth to grab this language where convenient is really obvious once
spk_0
you know to pay attention for it. And the left speaks it fluently, particularly the academic
spk_0
campus left. And that's what he's a creature of. I just don't look, I mean, let's put it this way.
spk_0
I grew up in New York City. Where did you grow up? I can't remember. You were like a
spk_0
silly kid. Born in upstate New York, Utica. And then my father's working for the mayor of Utica. He
spk_0
lost his election mayor, Osaro. We moved to Canada because my dad got a job selling Israel bonds
spk_0
in Toronto. And I basically grew up there, which also by the way has a crazy socialist mayor right
spk_0
now Toronto, but that's a separate subject. With the possible exception of Chicago, there is no
spk_0
city in America, I think, that is more viciously punitive of politicians who failed to collect the
spk_0
snow after a big snowstorm. So by all means, talk all you want about the cleansing power of
spk_0
anti-colonial violence and drop as many friends, fan and quotes on me as you want. If he doesn't clean
spk_0
up the snow after a big snowstorm, that's going to be a bigger political problem for him than all of
spk_0
this stick. And I think a lot of it is is stick because he doesn't know anything else except how to
spk_0
speak this language at seminars and conferences. But mayor of New York City is like a real hands-on,
spk_0
you know, is the garbage union going to strike? If the number of people get pushed off of heaven
spk_0
forbid, get pushed off subway platforms increases 5% once he is sworn in, his solidarity with the
spk_0
liberationist movements of the third world will mean nothing to the median New Yorker.
spk_0
Okay, so I want to now look at the right. So over the past couple of months, as you know, well,
spk_0
you've been covering this for a while. As you said, you were covering it long before it was
spk_0
cool. Tucker Carlson and others have been practicing some form of, I don't know what to call it,
spk_0
ju-baiting, Israel baiting. And he recently has gotten a lot of coverage had on his show us a series of
spk_0
anti-Jewish conspiracy theorists who's been basically almost every episode for the last year and a half
spk_0
has featured one of these guests, Holocaust revisionists. And then last week he had...
spk_0
We should also just point out just contrary to rumors in his own PR and things that people say in
spk_0
his defense about how he asks tough questions and he's a fearless guy who speaks truth to power.
spk_0
He asked virtually no difficult questions and offered no intellectual pushback to Holocaust deniers,
spk_0
to people who said Churchill is the real villain of World War II and to this gripper neo-Nazi guy
spk_0
Nick Fuentes. He basically gave them softball, tell me more interviews.
spk_0
Compared to for instance when he interviewed Ted Cruz about his support for Israel where he literally
spk_0
cut him off every sentence and just pounded him. Okay, so he has Nick Fuentes on last week who is
spk_0
again by all accounts, a neo-Nazi or sympathizer of Hitler's and as he said, Stalin's, I mean the
spk_0
whole thing was kind of nuts. He tweeted he's on team Hitler. So like that's a good heuristic,
spk_0
it cuts through a lot of like what should we call him? He's on team Hitler, right? Okay,
spk_0
there you go. Okay, so I want to play a clip from that interview so let's just play it and then
spk_0
we'll have you respond to it. You cannot actually divorce Israel and the neo-cons and all
spk_0
those things that you talk about from Jewishness. You say on your show that we need to treat Israel like
spk_0
any other country. Yeah, but Israel is unlike every other country in the sense that because the
spk_0
Jewish people are in a diaspora all over the world, they're a stateless people, they're
spk_0
resist assimilation. Let's say in the United States, for example, somebody like a Sheldon Adelson,
spk_0
he's not Israeli, his heart is in Israel and it's because he is a proud Jewish person. It's sort
spk_0
of a rational self-interest politically to say, this is not really my home, my ancestral home is in
spk_0
Israel across borders, extremely organized that is putting the interests of themselves before the
spk_0
interests of their home country. What's happening here? There's a term from political science that I
spk_0
think is most apt. I think it's called horse shit. This is, I mean, look, first of all,
spk_0
America's a country of immigrants. I think something like 50 million Americans right now are either
spk_0
immigrants or first generation Americans. You know who else has a diaspora where they care about
spk_0
their home country pretty much every other group in America. Indians, Greeks, Poles, Ukrainians.
spk_0
I mean, Irish don't get me started, right? Not to do a whole John Belushi skit. My point is,
spk_0
is that it's, it is a classic argument of anti-Semites to render invisible all the other examples
spk_0
that Jews fit and say, ah, see, Jews are all alone. It's why I argue that according to the logic
spk_0
of the left, the UN is structurally anti-Semitic because it excludes all other nations from a standard
spk_0
that they only apply to Israel, right? And we don't have to go all Hillel, Nour on this and
spk_0
cite all the times. It's singled out for stuff that often Israel didn't do. But even if it did do,
spk_0
it would make it no different than dozens of other countries. So this, this Jewish exceptionalism
spk_0
argument is a rhetorical trick that I don't have a lot of patience for. One of the things that
spk_0
conspiracy theories are for and why they're so successful these days is that conspiracy theories
spk_0
are a way to pander to the intellectual vanity of stupid and ignorant people. It is a way to say,
spk_0
you don't actually have to read a book. You actually don't have to know the facts. Here is this
spk_0
elegant, subversive, transgressive, intuitively plausible thing. If you didn't know anything else,
spk_0
that lets you sound sophisticated. Like, oh, you believe all these experts who say we landed on the
spk_0
moon. You know, I've done my own research by listening to Candace Owens and here's this other
spk_0
theory. It was a movie set, right? And that's what Tucker panders to. That's what Nick Fuentes panders to.
spk_0
Fuentes also, and to the certainly send Tucker, panders to this obsession among a large,
spk_0
but not nearly as large as people think it is, cohort or demographic of alienated, bitter young men
spk_0
who are poorly socialized to one extent or another. Like, we live in an age now where we celebrate
spk_0
people. This is a big part of my books who decide the West is that according to romanticism,
spk_0
the highest arbiter of moral truth or of any other truth is your gut or your instincts. Be
spk_0
true to yourself. Listen to your inner light, right? This kind of thing. And rebel against the system,
spk_0
rebel against the man. And when I would point this out about this tradition on the left, I used to
spk_0
get applause. The problem is it's a thing on the right now too. And on the right, what people want to
spk_0
do is get credit for questioning or challenging or violating taboos. The problem is we don't have a
spk_0
lot of taboos left in our society. And one of the taboos that is left and is deteriorating rapidly
spk_0
is not saying you're on team Hitler, right? Is not calling for, you know, like making jokes about,
spk_0
you know, putting people in ash trays at Auschwitz, right? But like gets a rise out of people. And
spk_0
that's what these guys are trafficking in. And because it gets a rise out of people, it is seductive
spk_0
to a whole bunch of people who want to feel rebellious and transgressive and all that kind of stuff.
spk_0
I think there are some truly horrific people who love Nick Fuentes, who are horrible human beings.
spk_0
I also think there are just a bunch of confused dopey people who would not be the Jew in the street
spk_0
or any of that kind of stuff. Actually, I think that kind of behavior is much more prevalent on the left
spk_0
because that has to do with the politics of Israel. And let's put it this way, a different
spk_0
diaspora that doesn't like the Jewish diaspora. Well, I'll put it this way. You said earlier about
spk_0
our friend, Tavitroy being a come to wearing Yamaha, that sentiment, I know a lot of Jews,
spk_0
I have a colleague, a close friend of mine who three or four years ago was attacked for wearing
spk_0
Yamaha. I have one of my rabbis, I have several rabbis. One of my rabbis says that he, I'll say,
spk_0
you know, David Hingberry, I mean, he said it himself publicly that he is often when he's
spk_0
walk around New York City, he has to think twice about wearing Yamaha. This is long before,
spk_0
this is a few years ago. So, and by the way, they don't feel that way. I'm just going to say it when
spk_0
they're in Oklahoma or South Carolina or Texas, they feel it in New York City and it's not like a bunch
spk_0
of knit Fuentes acolytes that they're worried about being attacked by on a New York City subway.
spk_0
Right, that's my point is that this is much more of an online phenomenon and also sort of a
spk_0
campus politics kind of phenomenon that doesn't mean it's good. Oh, let's put it this way.
spk_0
There are a lot of resistance types on the left, right, who really, really hate Trump. And I am not,
spk_0
I think we can all stipulate I'm not a big fan of Trump. But I'll say things like Trump isn't Hitler,
spk_0
Hitler could have repealed Obamacare. And they'll get mad at me. But oh, why are you making
spk_0
apologies for him? And like, I don't know, maybe again, because as I grew up with the name Jonah
spk_0
Goldberg, you can figure out why I think you can criticize someone and say they're doing bad things
spk_0
or say they have flawed character, but still saying they're better than Hitler. Right, I mean,
spk_0
like Hitler is supposed to be pretty much 10 out of 10 of badness. That doesn't mean if you're
spk_0
a six on a 10 on a scale of one to 10 of badness, that you're great. Right. But in this area of
spk_0
negative polarization, people think that any sort of nuance about these things is ridiculous. And
spk_0
so I think that's a lot of what Fuentes is tapping into. It's working. It's what Candace Owens is
spk_0
tapping into part of it. I think it people need to understand as a matter of politics.
spk_0
Some of it is related in a certain way to like the Jeffrey Epstein stuff. And so far as
spk_0
there are people who make their money online by basically monetizing dopamine hits,
spk_0
making people angry, putting thumbs in eyes and questioning taboos and all that kind of stuff.
spk_0
And one of the reasons why Trump couldn't silence everybody about Jeffrey Epstein is a lot of people
spk_0
are looking for the era after Donald Trump, like post Trump era. And one of the only business
spk_0
models that works for a lot of these people is like Jeffrey Epstein stuff or are going after the
spk_0
Jews and Israel. And it is a kind of a function of what is the next money play for a lot of these
spk_0
people. What is the next way to hold on to an audience now that MAGA is kind of entering its
spk_0
final stages. And the thing that I mean, I don't want to hijack the podcast here, but the thing
spk_0
that drives me absolutely back, Guano crazy about all of this, right, is and it just wrote about
spk_0
this is that you remember the Bush years and the Warontaire and the Iraq War, there are all of these
spk_0
people who on the left who did this sort of what I call bravery on the cheap, this performative
spk_0
courage. Well, you know, George Clooney would use his Oscar acceptance speech to denounce George
spk_0
W. Bush and you get massive applause for his courage from an audience that agrees with him entirely
spk_0
and loves him, right? And like they were the green as if they agree to these heroes. I know. And
spk_0
they would all go around saying Bush is Hitler and it was precisely because Bush wasn't Hitler
spk_0
that they could get away with saying this because if Bush was Hitler, you wouldn't say it because
spk_0
you be thrown in a concentration camp, right? Martin Neemoller was thrown in a concentration camp
spk_0
and so this sort of performative fake speaking truth to power thing drives me crazy. It's now a
spk_0
problem on the right Donald Trump, you can make an argument. I think you're probably sympathetic to
spk_0
it. I know John Padoritz is our mutual friend that with the expossible exception of Harry Truman,
spk_0
Donald Trump is the best friend Israel has ever had in the Oval Office. And I agree with that.
spk_0
It's open to criticisms. Maybe like there are nuances and all of that. That's fine. But I think as a
spk_0
top line observation, it's perfectly defensible. Right. It's certainly a lot of Israelis believe that.
spk_0
You know what Tucker Carlson doesn't spend a lot of time doing?
spk_0
Attacking Donald Trump for it. Candace Owens, maybe a little bit more. Nick Fuentes,
spk_0
once in a blue moon, what they do is they say, oh, he's being manipulated by the Jews, right? Or
spk_0
that he's a tool of the Jews that he's being let down by his advisors. There's a certain amount
spk_0
of like if only the czar knew kind of talk going on here. And it's precisely because the Jews
spk_0
don't control the weather and they don't have lasers that can take you out from orbit that they
spk_0
feel utterly safe and saying this. This idea that you can't say anything about Jews or Israel
spk_0
without being canceled. You're a more granular student of the New York Times coverage of the last
spk_0
three years. Seems to me there's a lot of criticism of Israel in the New York Times. The UN
spk_0
is a professional anti-Israel organization. You have countries denouncing Israel right left and
spk_0
center. You have books. You have courses at major universities that are all about denouncing Israel.
spk_0
It reminds me of when Peter Bynard wrote his first piece where he broke with Israel. This PC
spk_0
wrote eight, nine, ten years ago for the New York Review of Books. And it was a big break with
spk_0
Israel. I remember him saying at the time, this is the most difficult piece I've ever had to write.
spk_0
He was saying this is this like I'm putting it all out. You know, this could be the end of my
spk_0
whatever my career and it was like preposterous. This is actually the ease. I mean, if you're just
spk_0
thinking it from a careerism standpoint, it was actually the easiest piece to write because suddenly
spk_0
he was caving to the conventional wisdom and the media, you know, establishment mindset about
spk_0
all these issues. So it actually wasn't brave at all. Well, that's that's my point. It's like
spk_0
the massage not sending ninjas out after any of these people. And it is such a cheap, cheap claim
spk_0
of bravery that Tucker is trafficking here. And I do think Tucker is the, I'll hand the podcast back
spk_0
off to you and stop hijacking it. But like Tucker is the real male factor here. He is in the
spk_0
Rube Goldberg machine, no relation of what's going on on the right. He's the mouse spinning the
spk_0
wheel in a lot of ways. I know it's derivative of Tucker, but I do want to spend a minute on the
spk_0
Heritage Foundation, which you know, you look at the evolution, the modernization of the conservative
spk_0
movement, the Heritage Foundation played a very, I know you have you've always had your issues
spk_0
with the Heritage Foundation, but it played a very prominent role as a think tank. And now it's
spk_0
going through internal turmoil. So before we get to the internal turmoil, can you just briefly
spk_0
your student of all of the various organs within the conservative movement and their history? So
spk_0
what is the Heritage Foundation pre-mega and why did it matter? Yeah, it's up mattered a lot.
spk_0
Most of my criticisms prior to 10, 15 years ago, the Heritage Foundation were really wonky inside
spk_0
baseball think tank, nerdery that we don't need to get into. And for listeners, just for context,
spk_0
I'm an American Enterprise Institute guy. So it's sort of like softball team rivalry kind of stuff.
spk_0
So this Kevin Roberts, he comes out with a video a few days ago. I think many of our listeners have
spk_0
seen it where he, he refuses to condemn Tucker. He implies that platform ring figures like Fuentes
spk_0
is within the realm of legitimate discourse. And then there's blowback. And then he issues,
spk_0
you know, another video where he gives some stable where he apologizes to his staff and to the
spk_0
broader magick community, I guess, for his response. So tell me what's going on there. So you explain
spk_0
Tucker, you explain Heritage and now we're dealing with the blowback. So what is the blowback?
spk_0
And what does it tell us about where the right is today? So Robert's issues this video where he says,
spk_0
as you state, he says, you know, we don't cancel people. We believe in the no enemies on the right.
spk_0
Yeah, but also like we, we, you challenge bad ideas with free speech and all this kind of stuff.
spk_0
And just for the record, as a matter of logic and legal argumentation, right? If you, if you
spk_0
strip it of the other bad things and that thing, his position is indistinguishable from Claudine Gay
spk_0
and the other university presidents who were hauled before Congress and got ripped by Elise Daphonic,
spk_0
where those college presidents said those universities were policing speech all over the place.
spk_0
Like if you said men can't get pregnant, you got sent to reeducation or you got penalized or whatever.
spk_0
But if you said gas the Jews, they fall back into this, well, free speech, first amendment,
spk_0
it's difficult. You have to have these rules. That's Kevin Roberts position about Tucker having
spk_0
Nick Fuentes on is you have to make room in a free society and in our movement for the expression
spk_0
of virantly anti-Semitic ideas because we believe in arguments and free speech. That's, it was the
spk_0
exact same argument substantially as those university presidents. But he also said in his statement
spk_0
that the people who were going after Tucker and the Heritage Foundation were part of a quote,
spk_0
venomous coalition that were fighting on behalf of other people's interests. It was dog whistle
spk_0
upon dog whistle about how the Jews are doing this. At least that's the way it was reasonably
spk_0
interpreted. And it blew up in his face and lots of people condemned him and now he's in clean up
spk_0
mode. It's still ongoing just yesterday. He did an all hands meeting at the Heritage Foundation
spk_0
which immediately leaked even though it was great people on the in the meeting are saying we will
spk_0
fire anybody who leaks and by the end of the day the free beacon had the full video. I know the entire
spk_0
thing. Yeah. All two hours. Not even quotes. Just like a whole thing. And one of the more interesting
spk_0
things and I guess we're going to get into this in a bit in terms of the history of this problem
spk_0
on the right. Robert Rechter who is a scholar at Heritage who has been there for 47 years.
spk_0
And one of the points he makes, God bless him, is like you guys don't understand we've been here before,
spk_0
I'm this all paraphrasing, but we've been here before. One of the things that William F. Buckley
spk_0
did in the early 1960s was say we have to have zero tolerance for anti-Semitism, but also we have
spk_0
to have zero tolerance for crazy people because it undermines our non-crazy non-bigoted work.
spk_0
And Rechter was exactly right and the problem that Heritage has is because it's addicted to small
spk_0
donors. They are convinced that the energy and excitement of these young Fuentes following people
spk_0
in the Tucker fans and all that are essential to the Trump coalition. They really don't want to
spk_0
ex-communicate them. There's also an important, but we don't have to get deep in the weeds on it.
spk_0
There is an argument on both the pro and anti-tucker pro and anti-heritage sides that a lot of this
spk_0
is a proxy battle about JD Vance because JD Vance is clearly running cover for anti-Semitic
spk_0
Fuentes type people inside the Republican Party. When there was a group chat by these young
spk_0
officials, they weren't college kids as Vance claimed. These were young officials. One of them
spk_0
was an elected representative in Maine on their group chat talking about how they were, how
spk_0
based Hitler was or how we're going to round up the Jews and all sorts of just garbage horrible
spk_0
things. There's a big controversy about it and Vance ran cover for them saying I'm not going to
spk_0
there are a lot of these kinds of people. This guy Paul Engraziah who was nominated for a big
spk_0
position in the Justice Department. A different chat came out where he was talking about how he is,
spk_0
he does have a Nazi streak to him. Vance considers these people to one extent or another part of his
spk_0
base in some way. There are a lot of people who say oh by going after Tucker, you're really going
spk_0
after Vance because the reason why Vance is Vice President is because Tucker successfully lobbied
spk_0
for Vance to be Vice President. The original plan was that Trump wanted to pick either Bergham
spk_0
or Marco Rubio and the Pro Vance contingent which included Trump's sons and Tucker Carlson said
spk_0
you can't do this. According to reporting by Maggie Haberman who's been a Trump watcher for
spk_0
a zillion years and no one has refuted this reporting as far as I know, Tucker called Trump and
spk_0
said you can't pick Rubio because he's a Neocon who will want to start World War III and he'll have,
spk_0
I don't know if it said Israel, but he'll have you assassinated so he can be President.
spk_0
To say what you will, the fact that Trump listens to someone like Tucker is problematic.
spk_0
And so some people think that this is partly a stalking horse then getting back to my point
spk_0
earlier about the future of the GOP and the right, about which coalitions are going to be dominant,
spk_0
which ones are going to be exiled. This is one of the reasons why I have such contempt for these
spk_0
people who talk about we need to have a big tent and we need to have no enemies on the right and a
spk_0
broad coalition. But we must purge every last Neocon in the Republican Party. We have no more
spk_0
room for Nikki Haley's in this party. Well, wait, I thought you just said it was supposed to be a
spk_0
big tent. Do you mean it's just a big tent for Nazis, but not for like Nikki Haley? So there's
spk_0
a lot of bad faith in all of that, but that's one of the things that's going on in the background.
spk_0
Okay, Jonah, I want to bring together everything we just talked about and ask you about horseshoe
spk_0
theory and whether what we're seeing is the squeezing of the Jews from both the left and the right.
spk_0
But we'll pick this up on our inside edition of Call Me Back. That's it for our regular show. If
spk_0
you join us on inside Call Me Back, our members only feed, you'll gain access to an extended version
spk_0
of this conversation where I asked Jonah whether we are truly seeing the manifestation of horseshoe
spk_0
theory and where we take a step back and look at historical precedents where both sides of the
spk_0
political spectrum united against the Jews. To become an inside Call Me Back member, please follow
spk_0
the link in the show notes or go to arcmedia.org to get your own private feed. Jonah, thanks for
spk_0
having me. Real pleasure. Call Me Back is produced and edited by Alon Benatar.
spk_0
Arcmedia's executive producer is Adam James Levin Aready. Sounded video editing by Martin
spk_0
Huerego and Marianne Khalis Burgos are director of operations Maya Rakhoff. Research by Gabe Silverstein.
spk_0
Our music was composed by Yuval Semmo. Until next time, I'm your host, Dan Sienor.