Culture
Curiosity’s Search for Ancient Habitable Environments at Gale Crater, Mars
This podcast episode explores NASA's Curiosity rover mission at Gale Crater on Mars, focusing on the search for ancient habitable environments. The discussion highlights the rover's discover...
Curiosity’s Search for Ancient Habitable Environments at Gale Crater, Mars
Culture •
0:00 / 0:00
Interactive Transcript
spk_0
Thank you very much, Don. And once again, I thank everybody for inviting me. It's great to see some old friends and make some new friends.
spk_0
And I'm going to share with you what is about 10 years worth of effort in the mission.
spk_0
I won't be offended if people get a bit bored and leave. I was told it might be okay to go over my time a little bit.
spk_0
And I had a lot of fun with the robotics group. We actually met twice. So I stuck into some stuff I normally don't show to tell you about our flat tire on Mars.
spk_0
And I think that the place I really have to begin here is well with Mount Sharp, which is what we're exploring with the rover.
spk_0
The rover right about now is up on this ridge that you see right there. It's about 5 kilometers high this mountain.
spk_0
And the crater that we landed in is about 150 kilometers across. And so part of the problem that has nothing to do with habitability is what is this mountain doing in the middle?
spk_0
And I don't have a great answer for that. But we'll touch on it a little bit.
spk_0
Let's see here.
spk_0
Now that will work. Okay, so this is the part of the team that we were formed of when we first landed back in 2012.
spk_0
This is about 200 people that are responsible for the operation of the rover on a day-to-day basis. But the broader team is 500 scientists representing 13 countries, nine principal investigators, 10 instruments that make various measurements in addition to 17 cameras.
spk_0
So the goal, my responsibility was principally to make sure that the rover was optimized to create collect data and sort of keep moving in the same direction to create the path of discovery here.
spk_0
So really what I'm showing is a lot of data from instruments that I didn't build in science team members who contributed a lot to the data interpretation.
spk_0
I think what I want to do is start by talking about some of the things that puts Mars into a more Earth-like context so that some of you that are not geologists and geochemists can better appreciate what we're doing.
spk_0
And in my experience with Mars, it takes a long time to get used to it when you're used to working on the Earth. And there's a lot of history to learn about to go through.
spk_0
And so for me, this history really begins with the Mariner mission at back in the 60s, which is the first time that geologists ever got to see pictures of the surface of Mars that shows evidence for some kind of flowing fluid.
spk_0
And back in those days, they weren't sure it couldn't be liquid CO2 or even liquid nitrogen. But you see these channels back in the Mariner 9 data, Viking comes in about five years later with bigger and better cameras and the channels didn't go away.
spk_0
They just got more refined. And so as the decades went by, the debate slowed down and most people accepted that these were cut by water and then the question became what happened to that water?
spk_0
So it really becomes a story of environmental evolution. But the geologists really missed an important part of this problem, which is what happens to the mass that is represented by these channels.
spk_0
These are bedrock channels. Where does that stuff go? And so when I first got involved, I always wondered why aren't people asking this question about where these materials are that were eroded away.
spk_0
And so there was what I regard as a very big breakthrough by the Mars Global Surveyer mission, which took these pictures that showed unequivocal evidence for deltas in the rock record of Mars.
spk_0
And of course, if you conserve that mass, that's where it winds up. It goes downstream. But the most important thing is that the structure of this feature indicates that there's probably a body of standing water.
spk_0
And now the discussion of paleoclimate gets really intensive because the implication of a body of standing water is that it's an equilibrium with the atmosphere.
spk_0
So that Mars may have had an atmosphere that was more like earth. The channels that you saw in the picture before, you could be a flash in the pan.
spk_0
There's an eruption of water. It flows across the surface. It carves the channel. The water goes away. And the climate of Mars is not much different from earth.
spk_0
But what this picture really required for many of us was that there should someday be evidence for a lake.
spk_0
Okay, but before these rovers landed, all we could do was map. And so this was some mapping that was done by the team that worked back in the 1990s and early 2000s plotting the distribution of these channels, which basically straddle the equator.
spk_0
They're not observed at higher nor their latitudes. And then when I got involved, what I did with work with my students was to plot the location of just layered rocks that could be sedimentary deposits that would balance that mass on a global basis.
spk_0
And not surprisingly, where you see the evidence for erosion, you also see the evidence for deposition.
spk_0
But you don't know that these layered rocks aren't volcanic. You don't know that they're windblown materials. They don't have to relate to water.
spk_0
So it still requires vehicles and sit to to make measurements and show what these were.
spk_0
If you go back to the Viking era, again, the history of of laryning was shown in this first image that came back, where what you can see is that this valley, this this valus marinara, this this canyon is about five miles deep.
spk_0
And the upper reaches of the canyon, you see a light tone rock giving way to a dark tone rock, which is the loading and shedding material down across it.
spk_0
So that suggested that there was some wearing present in the upper crust of Mars, but we still didn't know what those things were.
spk_0
And this discussion went on for decades until the opportunity rover landed in 2004.
spk_0
And those of us that woke up in the morning and saw this this picture realized that this this really did have to be some kind of a sedimentary material, not a volcanic deposit.
spk_0
And so the cool thing about it is that you can see that everything below this white line is sort of tilted with respect to this line.
spk_0
And everything above it is flat line. And so you can see geometric discontinuities.
spk_0
And the fun thing about that is that we could fantasize a little bit that we were looking at sticker point.
spk_0
And we don't believe that our uncomformity represents the discovery of plate tectonics, but really it's kind of those you may recognize this fellow, and at least one person does, that's James Ray for scale there.
spk_0
And so the point is is that really what we do is comparative planetary analysis for the first time.
spk_0
And the analog that we do draw a comparison with is in the desert of Namibia where you see ancient sand dunes that weave behind this dipping strata as evidence of the migration of the dune, which is then deflated and overlaid by a water rich deposit, this pile lake deposit, it's dry most of the time, but it does get wet.
spk_0
And that turned out to be the signature of these sediments here. These look like ancient sand dunes deposits and these look like deposits that were formed in some type of a pile lake.
spk_0
But the geochemistry of this pile lake, that's something that Niktosco worked on, turned out to be very acidic.
spk_0
And so this wasn't the perfect place to make a case for if life ever evolved on Mars, could it live in that environment? That's what we mean by habitability.
spk_0
It's in existence proof, if life evolved, could it live in the place that you just discovered?
spk_0
And so here it's possible because some type of microorganisms do live in very strong acids, but it's not the perfect place.
spk_0
But in terms of sort of the modern environment, this is what we drew an analogy with and this was something that I got exposed to in the year I spent in the sultanative of a mine working with Bruce Levelle and others.
spk_0
You go out to the empty quarter and this is a type of environment that we think we had on Mars at the time.
spk_0
Generally very dry, but once in a while it rains really hard in the Oman mountains and then a hundred kilometers away, that rainfall eventually surges to the surface, maybe decades later after the rainfall, but it does get wet.
spk_0
And then that water is there temporarily and when it dries out, it leaves its salts behind.
spk_0
And this is what we think happened at that location we discovered with the opportunity rover was a salty acidic environment.
spk_0
Okay, at the same time that opportunity was making those discoveries of these sulfate salts that were there, there was a European Space Agency mission called Mars Express that had an instrument on it called Omega, which is an imaging spectrometer that was in the past.
spk_0
It looks down at the surface of the planet and it went back to these same valleys that I showed the picture of with the steep wall rock.
spk_0
And in this interior valley, which was very strange because there's just a closed depression here, which then goes into one of these eroded bedrock channels.
spk_0
And so this becomes a place where people imagine that maybe water gushed up and then ran out across the surface.
spk_0
But with the higher resolution imaging, what people noticed was that there was a mountain in the middle, it's just down in the corner here, it's that mountain right there, and it separated from all the rest of the rocks that go around the southern end of this enclosure.
spk_0
And the cool thing about it was when they looked at it, they found the same kind of salts that we found with the curiosity rover.
spk_0
And so this is a perspective view and this is about two and a half kilometers of relief here.
spk_0
And the interesting thing about it is you don't have to be a geologist to recognize that this stuff up here just looks different from everything that's down below this layer right here.
spk_0
And it turns out that if you look straight down on it, that's what this map is.
spk_0
And so this blue stuff that you see here is the top of the hill and the red stuff is the base of the hill wrapping around.
spk_0
And these are two types of salts. This is a magnesium salt and this is a calcium salt.
spk_0
And they have different solubilities and it all adds up to a story where probably there was water, but it was very salty and it dried out and they not have lasted for a long time.
spk_0
Okay. And so, but for me, I think as a geologist and a strategist, what was so exciting about this is that this is really the origin of the study of compositional layering on Mars.
spk_0
Because with the imaging spectrometers, you're not just mapping textures, you're also mapping the mineralogy of the rock at the same time that you map the textures.
spk_0
And so the state of that art, if you will, is not a lot different from the history of exploration in your country right here.
spk_0
And I really love to draw a comparison to this because effectively this is what William Smith did about 200 years ago when he mapped the layers of England and was able to learn much about their composition.
spk_0
And if you read the accompanying notes that go along with this map, he realizes that the discovery of these layers as materials will help fuel the industrial revolution.
spk_0
The interesting thing about this, if you look at the layers in cross section, they dip towards the English Channel.
spk_0
And the curious thing is that they just stack all different compositions, but this one here called chalk comes from the Latin word creta, which means chalk.
spk_0
And the important thing about that is this is a mineral name that follows the term cretacious to this day.
spk_0
So in Earth's own geological time scale, there is a period which is actually associated with a mineral.
spk_0
And this is kind of what we're doing with Mars right now.
spk_0
And for those of you that are not geologists, the most important thing that he was able to do, and followed up by his nephew, was able to trace the layers,
spk_0
because he was digging canals, and he was studying the layers in the canals, and he discovered that even though the composition and the minerals that are associated with these different rocks would change sequentially as you went upward in elevation, the fossils that you would see approximately follow the same order.
spk_0
And so he was really on his way to discovering evolution, although he didn't know it himself, but it fell to his nephew, John Phillips, to basically put together the first time scale that some divided the part of Earth's history we're most familiar with, into three phases, paleozoic, mesozoic, and senozoic.
spk_0
Of course, these are separated by major events in Earth's history that represent extinctions of organisms, but this is kind of what we're doing on Mars, but without organisms, at least so far.
spk_0
And so a geologic time scale is essential for us to keep going forward with the lecture here.
spk_0
It's a relative ordering of geological events, and if you're lucky, you get some absolute time constraints to tell you how old those events are.
spk_0
So we have a correlatable rock property, and it could be a succession of fossils, or like on Mars, we look at these reflectance spectra, and we see minerals, and maybe we can correlate these minerals around, and then you combine it with some kind of a substance that you can actually date.
spk_0
And on that basis, we build a geological time scale. So here's our relative time scale, and this is something that I worked on with a postdoc Ralph Milliken, and we took all the different strata around Mars.
spk_0
Don't try to read anything here. I know it's painful. Just look at the colors, and what you're going to see is that the rocks that are shown down here at the bottom are mostly green, and then they go into mostly red and yellow, and that's the top of the brown.
spk_0
That's all you need to know, and that this is older, and this is younger, and we're not exactly sure how old old is, and how young young is.
spk_0
But roughly, this goes from about four billion years ago to about two billion years ago, and then after that everything is brown. That means the planet's really dry.
spk_0
But down in here is where people get really excited, and if you go to this place, you find lots of green stuff, which are clean minerals.
spk_0
If you go to this place, you see them as well. But what was this one particular place really caught our eye called Gail Crater, where in principle, you could go from green stuff, what was thought to be just a little bit of it, then into the yellow stuff, and then into the brown stuff.
spk_0
Well, the greener clays, the yellows are these sulfate salts, and then the brown stuff is anhydrous iron oxide.
spk_0
So that's almost like John Phillips's three division subdivision of the history of the Earth 200 years ago.
spk_0
Okay, so that's a little bit of the background, and now we're going to look at this place, the Gail Crater landing site, which is the place that the science team voted for.
spk_0
And it's a fascinating place, because first of all, it straddles the Mars dichotomy boundary, and this boundary, what the dichotomy represents, is lowlands of the northern part of Mars,
spk_0
and highlands of the southern part of Mars, with this steep boundary in between here. And so this crater actually straddles the boundary.
spk_0
You can see the diameter of the crater here. It's similar to these other large craters, but these don't have mountains in the middle.
spk_0
So what's so weird about this thing? It just sort of captured our interest in our imagination, and then it turned out there were other important observations about the rocks that were in the middle of this mountain that resulted in us going there.
spk_0
And I heard a lot of interesting debates and arguments about why we should choose this landing site or that landing site, and it becomes a big mashup, and in the beginning there were about 60 landing sites with hundreds of people contributing ideas.
spk_0
And then in the end, we got the final four, and it became a decision of our team, and I had got to watch Bruce in action trying to figure out how to drill an oil well on a lawn.
spk_0
And at the end of the day, what I discovered was everybody was lobbying for their favorite prospect, and the problem was nobody was listening to anybody else. So we had to change things around a little bit, and then I had to go off and decide which one of these things we were going to spend two and a half billion dollars drilling.
spk_0
And in the simplest argument to me was all the fancy spectroscopy aside, as if you look at this landscape, you can see all these channels that we've known about since the 60s and 70s, we know that water runs downhill, and the color scheme here is topography.
spk_0
So the white colors are the lowest in elevation, and the northern part of Gail Crater with the exception of this crater over here is the lowest part of the planet for a thousand kilometers in any direction.
spk_0
So if you want to make sure that you land the vehicle in a place where there was probably water, that seemed like the simplest least sophisticated explanation, and we sort of went for it.
spk_0
Okay, so this mountain in the middle is interesting, and there's sort of two competing ideas. One of them is that you filled up a crater, and then you were rotted it away to leave a mountain in the middle.
spk_0
And the other one is, I call it the haystack idea, which is that they all started out flat like bowls, and the wind blew in a pattern that piled seven and on top of each other, and built a mound in the middle.
spk_0
But the authors of this paper, Malin and Edgitt, argue that there's almost like a history that can be observed in different craters, where you're mostly filled, and by the way, this is where the opportunity rover is, and the early days we called it Murby, and then it landed and it got named.
spk_0
But basically it's exploring the plains just outside of this enormous crater that's completely filled up, and then others look like they're starting to get evacuated, or alternatively they're not completely filled.
spk_0
And then as you work your way around in this direction, Gale represents sort of the N-member of what might be a continuum, and it suggests that maybe it is the result of erosion, and it seems to be that that is the case that we're really dealing with eroded layers.
spk_0
Okay, so it has the thickest stratigraphic section on Mars that takes us through those three periods, although we're only going to explore with the rover, the very oldest stuff, back at the time when there's supposed to be clays and sulfates.
spk_0
So here's our landing ellipse, which is about 20 kilometers in diameter, and because that landing ellipse was able to be shrunk down because of improvements in navigation and control of the entering spacecraft, we were able to land in this moat,
spk_0
and then the idea is that you land somewhere in the middle here, and then you drive out of the landing ellipse and up to the mountain.
spk_0
So we had to accept some risk that we might land on stuff that wouldn't be so good in order to drive along ways to get the stuff that is good.
spk_0
Okay, so again, just for the non-geologists, the reason we're interested in these layers, these stratigraphic layers, is because when you look at something like the stack of layers, either at Ciccropoin or down in the Grand Canyon, they're really records of environmental change, and that's what we're trying to do is to understand and reconstruct the environmental history of Mars to see if it could have ever been a habitable place for Mike Rorgonism's.
spk_0
So the history of robotic exploration on the surface, it began with landers, and on the Viking spacecraft, they included some very sophisticated experiments to see if there was extant life on Mars, and they all failed.
spk_0
So, for 20 years, they didn't find any evidence for life on Mars. Congress didn't like that, and so for 20 years there was no funding, and then eventually NASA came back, and in the mid-90s, we landed the Pathfinder Rover, and the argument was, let's just accept that modern Mars is probably lifeless, and get over that, and think about the ancient rock record when we see all the evidence for water that is now missing.
spk_0
But in order to find the right rocks, you need a mobile platform, and so this became what was known as a, it's not these two, these two rovers were associated with what were called missions, this was called a demo, because if it fails, it's not a failed mission.
spk_0
And so the sojourner Rover, six wheels, four wheel drive, the middle wheels are passive, rocker bogie suspension, so that you can drive over rocks that are equivalent to roughly the diameter of the wheels without tilting the deck of the vehicle, which is paved with solar panels.
spk_0
So if you tilt away from the sun for too long, that's bad, and so you don't want to have that happen. And so this was really an experiment with one instrument on it that could make chemical measurements of the rocks, and it was very successful.
spk_0
And so what happened was NASA got to go ahead to the next decade where we landed the spirit opportunity rovers, and you can see the heritage here, you have the same six wheel configuration with the rocker bogie suspension, the solar panels are much larger than they were on this one, because it's not a real thing.
spk_0
So we had learned more about the dust accretion rate on Mars, dust is always settling out, and if it settles out on a solar panel, you stop producing energy.
spk_0
So you have someone's certainty in the rate at which dust is falling down, so the way that you mitigate that risk is to double the surface area of it.
spk_0
We don't add windshield wipers, because NASA doesn't like moving parts if you don't have to use it.
spk_0
And then what you see are the cameras up on the mast here, whereas for this little guy, the cameras were on the lander, and the rover can never go very far beyond the lander, but the idea now is for this thing to go up on its own.
spk_0
They were designed to last three months and drive 300 meters each. Opportunity is still alive, 12 years later having driven 45 kilometers.
spk_0
So it worked pretty good, and then NASA got the thumbs up to go ahead to the next decade, because the goal of this mission was to prove what we had seen from orbit that there was this evidence for water once on the surface of Mars.
spk_0
We found that, and now what we do is build a much bigger vehicle that has a lot of sophisticated instruments to analyze the rocks for their chemical content in ways that isn't possible otherwise.
spk_0
Same six wheel configuration, rock with bogie suspension, cameras up on the mast here, a much bigger arm with a drilling rig at the end of it that takes us down seven centimeters.
spk_0
And in the back, instead of the solar panels, you have a slot that if Cape Canaveral, just like the astronauts would get in last, what we do at Cape Canaveral with this thing, is put in the radioisotope thermoelectric generator, which is NASA code for nuclear.
spk_0
And that goes in, and that's our power supply, and there's a thermocouple around it, and so all the heat that is generated is converted into electricity, and we generate about 100 watts of power per hour, and we have lithium ion batteries on board so we can store the excess power to the batteries, and then run off the grid at nighttime when we want temperatures to be cold for some analyses.
spk_0
Okay, so a lot of people ask, why does this work well? Why have there been this sort of string of technical successes with these vehicles working as well as they do?
spk_0
And what I learned in associating myself with these engineers is that there's no exception to this, that you test as you fly and you fly as you test, and you don't build anything that you can't test rigorously, and you don't do anything on Mars that you can't test first on Earth.
spk_0
And as a result of that, things generally work pretty well. What this engineer is doing is they have a little temperature sensor at the end, the rover is being illuminated with a light source that has the same intensity that the sun does on Mars, and they're trying to see what the temperature, what the skin temperature of all this metal is in response to that irradiation, to see how well it matches to the computer models, which predict the thermal behavior of the rover.
spk_0
Because thermal expansion and contraction on Mars, it's 100 degrees centigrade every day, and with all that titanium copper and aluminum going back and forth, that's the surest way to failure if you don't get that right.
spk_0
Okay, so we launched the rocket on day after Thanksgiving, back in 2011, takes about eight months to get towards Mars, and then eventually you enter the atmosphere, and everything looks kind of like the rest of these missions.
spk_0
But there were two big differences with the Curiosity mission. One was the guidance and control system associated with the part where it enters the upper atmosphere, and it ejects some ballast, and it becomes almost like an airplane plane wing, which means it can then be controlled, and the onboard computer has a location where it's supposed to land, and it's checking departures versus the inertial guidance system, and self-correcting for that.
spk_0
That's why we can land in such a tiny ellipse. So we fly out of most of those errors, and it looks like the other ones where parachute deploys the thing to celebrate, to subsonic velocities, but then it gets totally different from any other mission that ever landed.
spk_0
The heat shield falls off, and there's what's called a powered descent vehicle that flies out on its own with its own propulsion system, with the rover attached to the base, and then when it gets to be about 50 meters above the ground, it reels the rover out on a bridle of cables, and then the rover touches down, the cables are cut, but the scent stage goes off and crashes, and the rover is kind of born ready to go.
spk_0
So what it does is it reduces the risk that where the rover's in the past would have to unfold in all these complicated ways, if one of the devices doesn't work properly, the rover may be disabled.
spk_0
Okay, so it worked. And here's the first pictures we got, and this was really exciting because the engineers here all these semaphore tones, and they know it's going well, see people jumping up and down, but you're not sure why.
spk_0
And then this was one of the biggest battles I actually had with the chief engineer because the engineers, what's happening is when we land, we plan the landing so that Earth is still visible for Mars, and then we transmit data directly to Earth that tells us about the state of health of the vehicle.
spk_0
And the engineers would like to have all of the data volume, but the problem is people want to see pictures, and so they don't believe that things actually landed, and so the negotiation that I won was one picture, one black and white picture from one of the hazard avoidance cameras, and so what you can see here, 10 seconds after we land is when the picture gets taken, the lens cap is still, the lens cover is still across the lens, so that's all this dust that you see here.
spk_0
And then you get a glimpse, we were wondering if that could be the mountain that we had stared at from orbit for almost 10 years, wondering if we would ever make it there.
spk_0
And Earth sets, we get our data back, and then what happens is 39 minutes later, a satellite flies over the same site, and we're able to get more data, engineers again get virtually all of it, except for one more picture.
spk_0
And what you can now see that the dust covers have executed their command to open up, so you get a clear view, the shadow of the rover is longer by 39 minutes, and there's no question that our mountain is there, and we just have to get over there and start climbing.
spk_0
So that's all the data we get, and the rover lands at 1039 PM, and then the science team, the engineers that landed it go away and have a big party, and they're unemployed.
spk_0
And the scientists basically start working, but the problem is we have to work on Mars time, and the annoying thing about Mars is that it rotates once every 24 hours and 39 minutes.
spk_0
So every day, it's like getting in an airplane and flying two thirds of a time zone westward, and then you do it again the next day, and the next day, and the next day, and about every 40 days you come back into phase with Earth, you're away from your family, you're hold up in a hotel somewhere, painting the windows black,
spk_0
which is supposed to be sleeping during the day, and it's not much fun. But the great thing about it was there wasn't much to do, and we actually all went to bed, and we woke up the next morning, and discovered this.
spk_0
We had truly thought that nobody would be interested in this mission, because sojourns this cute little toaster-sized rover, and spirit and curiosity, or golf carts, and we've got this big SUV, and people are going to be bored with rovers, but what we totally missed was in between opportunity and curiosity, social media happened.
spk_0
And so we had a couple of videos that got released, and when the thing was successful, it just got spread all over the world, and everybody got into it, but the great thing about it is this is good, because the taxpayers feel like they're getting their money.
spk_0
They don't actually know really what science were doing, but that's okay.
spk_0
So then what happens is that eventually the data comes down, but you need to wait for a very high bandwidth handshake with the orbiters that are going around Mars, and we took a 360 degree panorama with color cameras, and we were also interested in the mountain in the middle that we had forgot that the crater rim itself is its own fairly imposing mountain range.
spk_0
And so this is about two and a half kilometers of elevation between where we landed, which is this really boring spot.
spk_0
It looks exactly like every other place the rover has landed on Mars, but the difference is you don't have to drive very far to get to bedrock.
spk_0
And so that was a cool thing about it. So the sky crane actually worked really well, it kept the rover away from all the interesting rocks, so we landed on this sort of featureless gravel plane with a bunch of gray rocks, but in the background, what we wondered was what were the best way to do it.
spk_0
And so we got to explore these layers because that was the whole reason that we were going there.
spk_0
So then eventually the rest of the 360 degree came around, and now we got the first images of the foot hills of Mount Sharp, and we decided that this was better than the crater rim.
spk_0
And the important thing what you're seeing here is that these layers from orbit, I'll show the data later or the interpretation of the data later, but these are all the things that showed these
spk_0
spectra for hydrated minerals.
spk_0
And that's important because it means that these rock layers form in the presence of water,
spk_0
but we just have to drive across here about 10 kilometers to actually get to the first rocks.
spk_0
Oh yeah, no, here's this slide.
spk_0
So here's where we landed right here.
spk_0
And this is where we need to go.
spk_0
In fact, we need to go all the way to this brown stuff.
spk_0
And honestly, we're about 200 meters away from it five years later.
spk_0
But the original goal was to land blast over here and start getting into all these layers.
spk_0
But as you can tell, we got way way.
spk_0
And in fact, rather than drive directly towards what we had to drive through these sand dunes that you see here,
spk_0
that's why we couldn't go this way.
spk_0
We had to drive all the way around and come through right here.
spk_0
But we'd actually drove in the opposite direction.
spk_0
So I need to explain to you why we did that because it turned out that we sort of hit the jackpot there.
spk_0
So this goes back to the mapping that we did before we landed.
spk_0
And again, what you're looking at here is that's a plot of topography.
spk_0
So these are lower elevations and the reds are higher elevations.
spk_0
And here's where we landed.
spk_0
This is our landing ellipse again.
spk_0
It's 20 kilometers in diameter.
spk_0
So we landed slightly off center, which is pretty good after going 300 million miles.
spk_0
And the landing ellipse is just in front of a feature.
spk_0
Not exactly the best developed thing we ever saw, but the geologists had pretty good agreement that there was a luvial fan
spk_0
that represents a sedimentary deposit derived from erosion of a channel back up here that cuts into the crater rim.
spk_0
And so the hope was that since we were basically landing downhill of this feature that showed evidence of water,
spk_0
that maybe if we did find rocks down in this area here, they would have something to do with water.
spk_0
That was very important because our primary objective is out here.
spk_0
But if we landed, break a wheel and can never get over here, I had to reassure the space agency that we would actually have something to do here that would be worthy of the mission.
spk_0
So we did a lot of this mapping.
spk_0
Here's a different map that plots a property called thermal inertia.
spk_0
And the way to think about this is if you're not used to it, is that your downtown, and it's a cool fall day,
spk_0
and you walk past a building late in the afternoon, you feel the heat radiating off at you.
spk_0
That's what's happening here.
spk_0
We're making observations at night from an orbiter looking down at the ground of heat being emitted in the thermal and for red spectrum.
spk_0
And so everything that looks like it's red here is just generating more heat than the material that's next to it.
spk_0
And it was interesting to us that the highest density of these red patches were out in front of this feature that we consider to be a luvial fan.
spk_0
And it led to two front runner hypotheses for what that might be.
spk_0
On one hand, maybe there's a lake deposit that's there, and everybody that wants to find water on Mars will be very happy because we'll see cemented rock where the cement
spk_0
derives from soluble minerals that precipitate from the water.
spk_0
On the other hand, there are the people that have been looking at Mars for decades that are convinced that the reason this thing is emitting so much heat is because it's a black lava flow.
spk_0
And that wouldn't be so good for $2.5 billion.
spk_0
I mean, it'd be great to do the geochemistry of the lava, but that's not the first priority for the mission.
spk_0
And so this went back and forth, actually, and it was pretty tense.
spk_0
But what you can see is that your land here, and when we realized, and we plotted our location, and we realized that's where we were, we just decided that for 500 meter investment of driving in the wrong direction, we could check out some of this red stuff.
spk_0
And so we dug in, actually, we did this mapping before we landed, and we made up kind of a surface materials map based on the textures.
spk_0
Here's the saluvial fan that we talked about.
spk_0
And then just based on the texture, we have fractured light tone terrain, created surface, smooth, hummicky, rugged.
spk_0
They're all sort of intuitive in terms of what you would see there.
spk_0
But here's where we landed.
spk_0
We actually landed on the smooth hummicky terrain.
spk_0
And then this fractured light tone terrain exactly coincides with that high thermal inertia material.
spk_0
And then the cratered surface over here looks like something you'd see on the moon.
spk_0
And so here it is.
spk_0
We decided to go and check it out because for a geologist, if you get to this point right here, you've got a three-fer.
spk_0
You can sample all three of these rock types, and even if they have nothing to do with water, it's still going to be cool.
spk_0
Okay.
spk_0
So two days after we landed the high-rise camera flow over and took a picture of the landing site,
spk_0
and here you can see curiosity for scale, and curiosity is two and a half meters long.
spk_0
And this very high albedo, this very bright thing that you see in the middle of the butterfly wings here, that's the rover itself.
spk_0
The butterfly wings are actually where the rocket motors blasted the soil away and exposed the bare bedrock.
spk_0
The dark patch that you see here is where the dust was blown away from the area.
spk_0
And then this is sort of the unadulterated background.
spk_0
Smooth hummicky terrain, the cratered terrain, and the light tone fractured terrain.
spk_0
And so our goal was to basically drive at explainess to NASA.
spk_0
So five football fields, and we'd be there.
spk_0
And we had a list of hundreds of names that we had to choose from.
spk_0
And so we had to give a press briefing, and I was in a bit of a hurry, so I told the team,
spk_0
somebody please pick a name.
spk_0
And I don't know if you guys know Kevin Lewis, but he came up with this name,
spk_0
Glenel, because it's a palimed drone.
spk_0
And so it was reassuring that we'd get the same thing when we changed our direction and went from backward to forward.
spk_0
So that was the reason that we picked it.
spk_0
But Glenel and Scott actually picked up on this, and you can Google it,
spk_0
and they now celebrate Mars Day once a year.
spk_0
They adopted it.
spk_0
So when we got there, we drove across this terrain, and then we got out onto these,
spk_0
you're going to see a picture from the ground of this ledge.
spk_0
Okay, here's the ledge.
spk_0
And this is us crossing the boundary between the smooth Hummicky terrain to the late-tone
spk_0
fracture terrain. Basically, the late-tone fracture terrain is solid bedrock, just covered with
spk_0
Mars dust. And this stuff has some gravel and chunks of rock and stuff like that,
spk_0
windblown sand, and that's what sort of smooths it out.
spk_0
So the great thing about it was, is that when we got here, we realized that we really did have
spk_0
solid bedrock, and the question was, is it a lake deposit, or some kind of sedimentary deposit,
spk_0
or is it a volcanic igmeous rock? So we drove down in there, and we got close enough,
spk_0
and right away things started to get pretty interesting. First of all, the rock is cut by fractures
spk_0
that are filled in with some light-tone mineral, and we have an instrument that's a laser,
spk_0
and we hit it with a laser, got the spectrum back, and it showed it to be calcium sulfate.
spk_0
Another thing about it was, this rock looks like it's got a bad case in the measles. There's
spk_0
all these bumps sticking out of it, the geologists call concretions. You can see them down here
spk_0
where they're merging, and these things ultimately turned out to be quite high in magnesium and
spk_0
iron. It turns out that they're a carrier of clay mineral. So then the time came, we decided that
spk_0
this was a great rock, and we wanted to drill this material and see what it was mineralologically.
spk_0
So we drilled the hole, and this is what it looks like, and what you can see is that those same
spk_0
light-tone things that you saw on the surface, they run down, they're three-dimensional,
spk_0
they are filled fractures. Here's the array of points where we shot into the hole with a laser,
spk_0
and this one up here hit some of the white stuff, and so we got confirmation that that was
spk_0
calcium sulfate in the third dimension, and then we also began to, again, see that there was
spk_0
some enrichment in magnesium and iron, but the problem is when you look at the bulk chemistry
spk_0
of this rock, it's perfect basalt. And so all the people that wanted it to be a lava flow,
spk_0
it's kind of like the spoiler really wants to win. They're like, it just looks like a lava flow,
spk_0
but the problem was, when we drilled it, and we did the mineralogy, we got something really different.
spk_0
And so rock nest is a modern-day Martian soil that we analyzed with a bunch of unaltered
spk_0
basaltic rock fragments in it, and these are all the minerals that make up a rock that geologists
spk_0
called basalt, major minerals, and here they are in their normal abundances, and then here
spk_0
they are in this hole that we drilled, and you can see how they're all decreasing in importance,
spk_0
especially this one called olivine, which almost goes to zero, and then we see the appearance of
spk_0
a clay mineral called smack-type, it's actually an iron magnesium smack-type, and this only forms
spk_0
in water, and it's in here at the 20 to 30 percent level. And then there's another mineral,
spk_0
which is a very minor component of the soil, which turns out to be an important component of this
spk_0
rock. Niktoska and his group have been doing a lot of work on this, and this is also a very
spk_0
important constraint on the fact of this rock representing an altered deposit. I'm going to show
spk_0
other pictures later on of some even better lake deposits than this one, but our interpretation
spk_0
was that this was an ancient lake deposit. Okay, I want to explain some of the data from the most
spk_0
sophisticated instrument on the rover. It's called SAM, which stands for sample analysis at Mars,
spk_0
and what you do is you take the rock powder, you drill, the rock powder goes down into the rover,
spk_0
and then it goes into what's called the sample manipulation system into one of these quartz
spk_0
cups, and then that quartz cup goes into an oven, and we heat it almost up to a thousand degrees
spk_0
centigrade, and cooking it, we release all the volatile materials, and we collect those gases,
spk_0
and then we analyze them in this spectrometer that we can feed it off that way. We can close a valve
spk_0
and send it down to a different kind of a spectrometer, a tunable laser spectrometer. This actually
spk_0
allows us to determine isotope ratios of water as well as carbon and oxygen, and then we can turn
spk_0
another valve and send it across something called a hybrid carbon trap, which is super cold,
spk_0
and then all the gases condense, and then we can turn the valve again and heat it up, and then
spk_0
liberate those gases and put them into something called a gas chromatograph, and from that maybe get
spk_0
a sense for what organic materials might be present on the surface of Mars.
spk_0
So here's what the data looks like as it's processed and comes out. This is the intensity of this
spk_0
quadrupole mass spectrometer. This is temperature rising from about 250 degrees C up to about 800,
spk_0
and the first thing that happens is we produce a lot of carbon dioxide comes out of the rock.
spk_0
There's a lot of water that gets produced. There's oxygen that comes out. The carbon dioxide peaks,
spk_0
and then after that the water peaks, and then the water production drops off until you get up to
spk_0
about 700, 750 degrees C, and then the water abundance comes back again. And what's happening there is
spk_0
that in this clay mineral, that clay mineral has water in its mineral logic structure, you're liberating
spk_0
that water, and it turns out we can actually capture that water and analyze it with the tunable
spk_0
laser spectrometer, and get its isotope ratio so we can measure the isotope ratio of water in
spk_0
rock on Mars that's almost 4 billion years old. And then this stuff down here, these are two forms
spk_0
of sulfur that come off sulfate and sulfide, and so this was very important in giving us an
spk_0
interpretation of the rock. I won't go into the details, but it can be simplified into a
spk_0
convenient story of pictures. And 10 years ago, well longer than that now, this is what we
spk_0
got with opportunity. We found this wet environment, and we were led there by a signature that we saw
spk_0
from orbit, and we didn't have a drill, but we had kind of a rasp. And when we rub the rock,
spk_0
it roads away, and the powder that is produced is red, and the rock itself is red, and it turns
spk_0
out this is associated with a mineral called hematite. And we think that hematite formed in water,
spk_0
but the important thing is, as Nick was able to show with his postdoctoral research, this was
spk_0
super salty and very acidic. It just wasn't that good of an environment. When curiosity drilled
spk_0
this mudstone, you can see that Mars is still red on the surface, but when you scratch below it,
spk_0
you now get a gray rock. And what that means is that the iron in that rock is not oxidized,
spk_0
like it is here, it's actually more reduced. It's in this mineral called hematite.
spk_0
And so these are two rocks from a similar kind of environment on earth. It's a triassic rift
spk_0
basin from Connecticut, and in New York, Boston, and Washington, DC. You have brownstone buildings
spk_0
that are brown because of these kind of red sandstones. And then you have gray rock, which is
spk_0
herb organic matter. So we got really excited about this because we have a much better chance to
spk_0
preserve organic materials on Mars in this kind of rock than this kind of rock.
spk_0
So the opportunity, if you reconstruct what Mars might have been like at that location,
spk_0
this was our favorite analog. It's a place called Rio Tinto in Spain. And there's a massive
spk_0
iron sulfide deposit, which is being oxidized and weathered. And all that sulfide gets converted
spk_0
to sulfate that produces a huge amount of sulfuric acid. And the acidity is so low that iron
spk_0
is actually soluble. And so the Rio is Tinto because iron is actually in the FE plus three state
spk_0
that dissolved in this water. And then this material that you see in trusting these rocks here
spk_0
is a sulfate salt called gerocyte. And you put that together, and this is the stuff that made up
spk_0
these rocks that Nick documented back at the opportunity landing site. There are microbes that
spk_0
grow there, but it's a very specialized group. So it is possible that this environment is habitable,
spk_0
but the reason this environment is habitable is because this is not that salty. It's salty, but
spk_0
it's not that salty. The rock on Mars was far saltier than seawater. And we think it was actually
spk_0
an uninhabitable environment for the same reason that honey keeps on your shelf. Honey is an
spk_0
aqueous environment, but bacteria don't grow there because the water activity is so low. So that
spk_0
was kind of the bummer for that site. It wasn't the acidity. It was the salinity. This is kind of
spk_0
what we think we discovered with curiosity. Just take these higher grasses away. We don't think
spk_0
they were on Mars. And this is actually drier than what we think we had. These are plialakes. They
spk_0
dry up seasonally, but it doesn't really matter because what happens is if you just dig a shallow
spk_0
hole, the water is still down there. So even if the surface is dry, it's still saturated down here.
spk_0
Microbes go really well because this is this rock called the salt, which weatheres in place
spk_0
in these lakes to form these iron magnesium smack-tight minerals that have a very similar composition
spk_0
to what we found on Mars. Okay, so this is what it comes down to. We don't think that the honey was
spk_0
a habitable environment. And what we think we found was sort of like a rock battery where microbes
spk_0
that actually harvest chemical energy, just like the chemical energy that stored in a battery,
spk_0
you can store it in a rock. And you just need iron in two different oxidation states. We found it.
spk_0
And you just need sulfur in two oxidation states. And we found that as well. So in microbe could have
spk_0
been very happy in this environment. That doesn't mean they were there, but it supports the case to
spk_0
look on in the next decade and now NASA is planning the next mission. So here's what we discovered
spk_0
with the organics. It turns out to be very difficult to do this on Mars and I'll explain why in a minute.
spk_0
But I mentioned that the first thing we did was to scoop a soil. And so what we're doing here
spk_0
is plotting the abundance of a compound called chlorovenzine. This is the most sophisticated molecule
spk_0
that we have found. But it turns out it's distributed in a very distinct way. So this is the
spk_0
detection limit for the instrument. So there is some positive value here, but we don't think that
spk_0
it's noise. So we don't think there's any of that stuff in there. Then we drilled this first
spk_0
hole. Remember here's the, you can see the spots from the laser, here's the sulfate filled fracture.
spk_0
And we drilled that we didn't find any of that stuff, but then we drilled another hole with a
spk_0
hypothesis that if we go to the highest concentration of all the concretions, maybe the concretions are
spk_0
preserving something that got destroyed everywhere else. So when we did that, this is where we found it.
spk_0
And it's statistically significant that those molecules are there. So their absence here really
spk_0
suggests that these organic compounds are somehow related to Mars. So to be sure of that,
spk_0
before we published the paper, we then went to the next rock type, which was a cross-bedded sandstone,
spk_0
where we didn't expect to see much of this stuff. And indeed, we didn't measure any of it,
spk_0
which means we're not even passing it forward as contamination from the previous drill hole.
spk_0
So we don't really know what this means when it comes right down to it. We're not even
spk_0
sure that we're not manufacturing these when we heat the rocks up by taking other organic matter
spk_0
and taking chlorine from Mars and then combining it together to manufacture this synthetic molecule.
spk_0
We're just not sure, but the fact that there's an abundance of it here suggests that it's worth
spk_0
while to go back and collect this rock and return it to Earth. Okay, so we got all excited.
spk_0
I have a special issue of science where we publish all our papers, and this is a location of the drill site
spk_0
that made it on the cover. And I was up at AGU, and we as a team were presenting these results
spk_0
that was in December of 2013. So the cool thing about it was the mission is funded for two years.
spk_0
And you get two years to basically discover something that validates the mission. And we found
spk_0
that after just six months, and it took us a while to work up all the results. And so all this stuff
spk_0
was found here in a place we call Yellow and I've Bay. And then after that we high-tailed it. And the
spk_0
idea is to drive as fast as you can over to the good stuff. And then we stopped it chemarily, and the blue,
spk_0
these blue circles represent where we did our first drill holes. So this is where we drilled that
spk_0
cross-betted sandstone, and we waited to make sure there wasn't any of the chlorobenzine in that hole
spk_0
so that we can make the argument that what we did find in the hole back here was really indigenous
spk_0
to Mars. But as we were driving along, we discovered that this smooth hummicky terrain actually
spk_0
wasn't so smooth and hummicky. And literally we had just presented the results and the mission
spk_0
manager called me up and said, you need to come back, there's a problem. And so we're going to stop
spk_0
driving. And so what you can see here is in these images that the saw is a day on Mars, 24 hours
spk_0
at 39 minutes. And after 400 of these days, we had picked up the fair number of dings and tents,
spk_0
and we expected to see that. But what we didn't expect to see was this tear that you can see over
spk_0
here. And so we went back and we started to look at all the terrain and we're trying to figure out
spk_0
how in the world that this wheel would get damaged. So what we did then was we aimed the cameras
spk_0
at all six wheels and we rotated all six wheels and took a complete set of pictures and we discovered
spk_0
that it was actually much worse than we had realized. These holes are supposed to be there.
spk_0
This array of three lines spells JPL and Morse code, it's clever engineers. And this hole just
spk_0
is bad. You're not supposed to see daylight through on their side there. And that brought the
spk_0
mission to a grinding halt. And we hadn't really made it to the place where we're ultimately supposed
spk_0
to be going, but it took us about six months to work through this. So here we catch the culprit
spk_0
and the act. And what you can see is that we're driving over these rocks that have these sharp
spk_0
pointy edges and it turns out that the wind is howling in this place that we landed. And it's
spk_0
turning all the rocks into pyramidal shapes that geologists are familiar with in places like
spk_0
Antarctica and other deserts that are very sharp. And the wheels honestly were just under-engineered.
spk_0
They just couldn't bear this strength and we didn't expect to encounter this many rocks. And
spk_0
the wheels were made to be lighter than what you might have wanted to do because that helps with
spk_0
the physics of the landing problem if the rover weighs less than the master vehicle does.
spk_0
So we did some tests and we divided up and I went off with all the scientists and we tried to
spk_0
figure out how can we get less of these rocks. And the chief engineer went off with his group
spk_0
and they did some experiments. So here you're going to see the results of these.
spk_0
Let's see.
spk_0
So we call this thing named Taylor and so we're basically driving the vehicle across it.
spk_0
And what's happening is this. The pivot point for the wheel is in front of the lever.
spk_0
And so what you're trying to do is basically push this thing across horizontally which not only
spk_0
gives the static load associated with the acceleration of gravity on Mars acting on the impeller.
spk_0
It gives you a dynamic pressure pushing into it. So the idea became what if we drive backwards
spk_0
and pull the wheels behind us? It's actually basic physics. But it took us six months to figure this
spk_0
out because we had to do all the testing. So here we are now. Same thing but driving backwards.
spk_0
So it worked. Okay, so that's the first part of the problem.
spk_0
Let's drive backwards. So we made the decision that we would now drive backwards as much as
spk_0
possible. You get four wheels that are trailing instead of four wheels leading. So there's
spk_0
two that are going to get pretty badly damaged. And then this is the part that I worked on.
spk_0
Here's where we stopped. And the black line that you see here is the route that we're supposed to be
spk_0
taking which is effectively the shortest distance between point A and point B, avoiding some of the
spk_0
craters in the sand dunes that you see here and adjusting for other things that look like scary
spk_0
terrain. And then so what I do is I chose, let's see, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven
spk_0
different scientists on the mission who I think have the most experience with thinking about terrain
spk_0
and geomophology. I give them all the data that they want. They get a week to go away and come up
spk_0
with a preferred route. So how many times have geologists ever seen this before? Seven different
spk_0
interpretations. And the reason why is because there is no hypothesis. It's just guessing. And so
spk_0
some people say let's take the high road. Other people say let's take the road. Some people
spk_0
say here's the guy with the green path is basically saying I don't care, I'm still going with the
spk_0
shortest route. And then the pink guy over here says let's take the longest route because that goes
spk_0
through the valleys and maybe the valleys actually have more sand and less rock. So that was a
spk_0
tough cell to NASA. We turned out to take the pink route because I'll show you why in a minute.
spk_0
But the NASA lead engineer is saying let me get this straight. You guys are going to take the longest
spk_0
route to keep the wheels safe. And so we had to do a little bit more work before they accepted it.
spk_0
So what we did was terrain mapping. So we actually blew the images up to their highest resolution
spk_0
and subdivided it into a whole bunch of terrain types that we interpreted to have properties that
spk_0
would be worse or better for the wheels. So what you can see here is that basically we're trying
spk_0
to stay on the green or the blue. And the green are ripples where we can see aolian windblown sand
spk_0
from orbit. And the smooth looks like it should be some kind of sand or soil. But what we're really
spk_0
trying to stay away with are these cratered cap rocks. And originally we thought we'd be better
spk_0
off driving on the rock to stay out of out of the sand. So the first challenge,
spk_0
gosh it's just off screen, there's a gap up here that we had to drive through.
spk_0
And to make it into this this network of valleys. And here's what this gap looked like.
spk_0
So what you can see is rocky plateau. These are all conglomerates and sandstones heavily cemented.
spk_0
And then here they are shedding all these sharp rocks down that we had been driving across.
spk_0
And there's a valley right here. But the problem is the valley is included by a single sand
spk_0
dune that bridges across here. So the problem is we have to make it across the sandstone,
spk_0
across the sandstone in order to make it down into a valley which we think is good. But we don't
spk_0
know it's good. So the NASA guys are all saying, how do you guys going to demonstrate this?
spk_0
And so we said, well the first thing we should do is just go up to the edge here and put the front
spk_0
wheels up here and peer over the top. Because our cameras kind of like a periscope. So here we are
spk_0
peering over the top. And you can see why you wouldn't want to go racing over the top because this
spk_0
cliff is collapsing to produce all these blocks. And if you drove straight across that would really
spk_0
be a problem. But what you can see in the distance here is that the terrain really does look pretty
spk_0
good. Like what we had thought we were seeing from orbit, you know there is some ripples. And then
spk_0
down here you can see some rocks strewn around. But all together this sort of sandy river looks
spk_0
a heck of a lot better than any of these other options that you see here. But the problem is now we're
spk_0
worried about getting stuck in the sand dune. So here we are doing an experiment. And this is an
spk_0
animated gif that shows 24 hours of data. And what you can see here is that we did literally come
spk_0
up to the brink. And we put the left front wheel just on top of the cross line of the sand dune.
spk_0
And then the right front wheel is just behind it because of suddenly we sink. We can still pull
spk_0
ourselves out. That's the idea. But what we do is we drive the vehicle up there and then we took a
spk_0
picture and then we wait 24 hours and take another picture to approximately the same time. But it
spk_0
wasn't exactly the same time. And that's why the shadows are a little bit different. But the
spk_0
important thing is you can see the shadows moving. But what you can't see moving are these little
spk_0
fractures in the sand dune or the wheels. It doesn't look like we're sinking. So with that we eliminate
spk_0
the risk. Not completely. But you know the mobility engineers are going to always invent every worst
spk_0
case scenario that could possibly happen. And so in this case it was yeah there's beautiful sand
spk_0
here. But one center beam beneath it is going to be baking flour. And you're just going to sink in
spk_0
anyway. So we got up the courage. We drove across it. It worked well and then we looked back at it.
spk_0
And so here's our tracks. And what you can see doing what we're doing here is driving over the
spk_0
cross line. And we command the vehicle to yaw on purpose. And so we over drive these wheels
spk_0
which steers us away from sliding down the front here and skidding into these rocks. And so we get
spk_0
most of the way down. And then you can see where we made a little trench here that comes from the
spk_0
wheel wiggle that we do to make sure that we've estimated the slip rates correctly. And then we just
spk_0
drive on. So that's what we did. And we made it through there. And we've been doing fine ever
spk_0
since. And here's where it took us eventually. We finally got to the place where we had told
spk_0
everybody that we were going to go to. And we're descending down to a place that became known as
spk_0
Armagosa Valley because the guy on duty was worked in death Valley and suddenly we had death
spk_0
Valley names. And this was this rock that from orbit it just doesn't show any signatures of
spk_0
hydrated minerals. It looks like it's going to be pretty disappointing. But what we had learned
spk_0
from our first drill hole is that that place didn't show any signatures either but it had 20%
spk_0
clan. And this was a big surprise in the Mars community because these rocks are relatively
spk_0
younger in the history of Mars and they're not supposed to have all this clay. And so the question
spk_0
was could we demonstrate that again as we drove even higher up into the stratigraphy of layers
spk_0
and this became our chance to do that. So we worked along and again just to give you the frame
spk_0
of reference that image that you saw here. These are the front hills. We were parked right here
spk_0
looking down into this Armagosa Valley. And then ever since then we've been drilling and we've
spk_0
got through four more drill holes that I haven't plotted. But conceptually this is what we learned
spk_0
as we drove the vehicle uphill. This is a plot of elevation and this is the saw number that
spk_0
that we drove across. So here's saw 400 when we had all these problems where we tore the wheels up
spk_0
because we had basically driven only a short way and what we interpreted to be sandstones,
spk_0
river deposited sand that becomes a rock. And then we drilled into a mudstone and then we drove
spk_0
across more sandstone and tore up the wheels and then we learned how to drive around it. But we kept
spk_0
going uphill and all the rocks that we had been looking at looked like the kind of rocks that
spk_0
form in an ancient river or delta. And then right around saw 800 we crossed a geologic boundary
spk_0
that we could see from orbit. And ever since then we have been in what looks like a lake deposit.
spk_0
And now we've got it accumulated about 150 meters of that stuff. And we drilled as we went along.
spk_0
So this is sort of for the geologists in the room and I'll just leave this up here for just a minute
spk_0
because it's probably going to be our greatest accomplishment is the mineralogy that will
spk_0
distinguish us from previous rover missions. And what we're really interested in are these
spk_0
kinds of things, what the brighter colors that you see down here. These were the holes that we
spk_0
drilled originally and we wrote our science papers about. And here this green stuff in here
spk_0
gets missing from the legend. That stuff is missing. This is this iron magnesium clay.
spk_0
Okay, so every place you see the green means we have this iron magnesium clay. The black stuff
spk_0
is the magnetite which we think somehow is forms an association with that clay production and
spk_0
Nick Tosca has some good ideas. So we left those rocks and when we got to the Perump Hills we found
spk_0
more clay but we now had hematite in addition to magnetite and we had some of these less common
spk_0
sulfate phases that you see down in here especially this iron sulfate which actually now suggest
spk_0
we're getting into some acidity that we didn't have before. But then something really dramatic happens
spk_0
when we go up to these next we get up higher into the section. Most of it the hematite goes away.
spk_0
Then eventually it goes completely away. All of these acidic sulfate minerals go completely away
spk_0
and we have a large amount of crystalline silica mostly in the form of crystal ballite and
spk_0
tritomite. And so we actually think that there might have been some some phelousic amius rocks
spk_0
that were contributing to tritus to the basin but the biggest part of this is actually a morphe silica
spk_0
that I'll show you in a minute. The thing is is that even though it looks like we stay in the lake
spk_0
the chemistry of this lake and or its subsequent diagenetic history are changing and so the place
spk_0
where we've been most recently actually has the most clays that we've seen of the entire mission
spk_0
but now we don't see any magnetite and we've just got a lot of hematite and we're picking up a
spk_0
lot more sulfate but we've never seen magnesium sulfate and we actually picked up mostly gypsum.
spk_0
So this looks surprisingly like the earth actually it's just it doesn't look like that weird
spk_0
stuff that we found 15 years ago at the opportunity landing site. So these are what these what we
spk_0
interpret to be these lake deposits on Mars. You can see the scale bar here these are centimeter scale
spk_0
sort of almost rhythmic looking deposits and if you compare them to ancient lake deposits on
spk_0
earth these are from Canada and these are glacial deposits this is actually a drop stone there.
spk_0
We haven't seen anything that looks like a drop stone but the fact is is that they're these are
spk_0
exactly at the same scale and so it's surprising actually how similar that seems to be and then
spk_0
this is what happens when you get this very high silica rock. This fabric that you see angling
spk_0
down through here is something created by the modern day wind eroding the rock but if you look
spk_0
behind that you can see very very fine lamination in there and you can also see that there are
spk_0
these these dense these what we think are voids because when you trace the surface of the rock around
spk_0
there's a lip like a ski jump right here and you can see these same holes in that so we think
spk_0
those are three dimensional features of the rock and in conversations with Nick what we're wondering
spk_0
is this rock is basically mostly a more facility a little bit of crystal in silica and a lot of
spk_0
magnetite and Nick has come up with a way to possibly make hydrogen in this reaction and it
spk_0
could be that these these are bubbles gas bubbles preserved in the ancient rock so if that does
spk_0
it's the case and talking with ray today you know hydrogen turns out to possibly have a capability
spk_0
to keep Mars warm so maybe we're now converging on a on a solution for the early climate of Mars
spk_0
so this is a paper that was just accepted yesterday into science by Joe Hurwitz who was a fellow
spk_0
graduate student with mech Tosca that extends to explain how you had a link but it wasn't all
spk_0
the same thing and it seems to have changed through time and here's the rock that has this very thin
spk_0
lamination that looks more like a magnetite silica face and then here's a rock over here that
spk_0
has more of a hematite phylasylicate association and I think in the interest of time I'm not going to
spk_0
offer a more detailed explanation of that other than to say that we think that it has something to do
spk_0
with mixing of ground waters with surface waters possibly in the presence of UV light that might
spk_0
create oxidation to generate acidity in order to explain this but if you get deep enough you don't
spk_0
see any of the acidity and maybe you have a more reducing environment it's not really similar
spk_0
but it is kind of haunting to think about the early history of the earth when we deposit a rock
spk_0
called banded iron formation where you see lots of silica fine lamination and associated with iron
spk_0
oxide it's mostly hematite but the fact is this is not entirely different from what we're seeing
spk_0
on Mars and there have been a number of explanations offered for these rocks but I'll just leave
spk_0
you to think about that and as my last slide I think that as we look at Mars we're really beginning
spk_0
to do comparative planetary subtology and geochemistry you really have to get a PhD in geology and
spk_0
geochemistry to to take apart Mars now and what you wonder is what about all the exoplanets where
spk_0
people are finding all these other possible habitable environments and so I think that it's all
spk_0
all looking pretty exciting thanks for listening