Technology
The Plague of San Francisco | The Golden City | 4
In this episode of 'American Scandal,' we delve into the battle against bubonic plague in early 1900s San Francisco, focusing on Dr. Rupert Blue's sanitation campaign in Chinatown. As t...
The Plague of San Francisco | The Golden City | 4
Technology •
0:00 / 0:00
Interactive Transcript
spk_0
Want to get more from American scandal? Subscribe to Wondery Plus for early access to new episodes,
spk_0
ad-free listening, and exclusive content you can't find anywhere else.
spk_0
Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.
spk_0
American scandal uses dramatizations that are based on true events.
spk_0
Some elements, including dialogue, might be invented, but everything is based on historical research.
spk_0
It's February of 1903 at San Francisco City Hall. Inside a packed hearing room, 34-year-old
spk_0
federal doctor Rupert Blue stands before a fractious meeting of local landlords.
spk_0
Dr. Blue is in charge of the Marine Hospital Service in San Francisco.
spk_0
He and his predecessors in the job have faced years of hostility from newspapers and politicians,
spk_0
but Blue has finally secured the backing of city and state authorities for a sanitation campaign
spk_0
to eliminate bubonic plague from the city once and for all. He has proposed a huge demolition
spk_0
scheme in Chinatown to sweep the cramped and unhygienic streets that provide ideal conditions
spk_0
for the disease to spread. But landlords in Chinatown are seeking a legal injunction to stop the plan.
spk_0
So if Blue is to move forward, he must win them over.
spk_0
He tries to raise his voice above the chatter.
spk_0
Gentlemen, if I may please just a moment of your time.
spk_0
Oh, thank you. Now, I understand these measures might sound radical.
spk_0
They sound crackpot as what they sound.
spk_0
Blue peers through the crowd. A pink face landlord at the back of the hall is jabbing a finger at him.
spk_0
You're asking us to tear down property we spent years building. And for what?
spk_0
Sir, if you don't mind waiting until the end, please I'll answer all your questions then.
spk_0
No, no, no, I don't have any questions. I have some statements.
spk_0
I own a row of properties between Stockton Street and Waverly Place and I will not see them
spk_0
destroyed. They are mine. Sir, I appreciate your concern, but rest assured,
spk_0
our plans do not include the demolition of entire buildings,
spk_0
just the balconies and stoops. And how will tearing down balconies get rid of the plague?
spk_0
That is a fair question, sir. And the answer is actually pretty simple.
spk_0
These balconies block sunlight and restrict airflow, leaving the streets below them,
spk_0
damn poorly ventilated, and vulnerable to rot and decay.
spk_0
So you're asking us to believe that a little sunlight is going to miraculously end the plague?
spk_0
No, sir, of course not. Sunlight alone will not achieve much.
spk_0
But combined with our other sanitary measures, it could make a real difference.
spk_0
Uh-huh. But who's going to pay for the price of all this disruption?
spk_0
It's going to be us, right? The landlords and the business owners who are just trying to earn
spk_0
an honest living here. Well, you're right, there will be some disruption, but we will try to keep
spk_0
that to an absolute minimum. And I promise we're going to work with the utmost efficiency.
spk_0
Well, I have a hell of an efficient fix for you. Why don't you get rid of the Chinese?
spk_0
They're the ones spreading this disease. Actually, certain, it is I say we have the move to
spk_0
Angel Island or better yet, back to China. Blue suppresses a sigh.
spk_0
For him, it's clear that the real blame lies with the landlords and their cramped squalad buildings.
spk_0
Still, Blue knows he must tread carefully because he can't afford to alienate these men.
spk_0
Gentlemen, gentlemen, look, look, I give you my word.
spk_0
If you support our efforts, my staff and I will work tirelessly to make this city healthy again.
spk_0
But you have to trust us. Because if we don't act now, this disease will not stay in China town.
spk_0
It will spread. It will spread to your families. It will spread to your homes.
spk_0
And I think you'd agree it's well worth losing a balcony or two to prevent that.
spk_0
Eventually, the landlords reluctantly agree to back Dr. Rupert Blue's campaign.
spk_0
Their threat of legal injunctions is dropped. And soon after, sanitation teams begin removing
spk_0
stupes, dismantling balconies and clearing away piles of rotting timber in Chinatown.
spk_0
They go from house to house, fumigating rooms, scrubbing down surfaces and sprinkling floors
spk_0
with chlorinated lime. And slowly, the district's familiar stench of decay is replaced by the
spk_0
accurate smell of antiseptic. Dr. Blue begins to feel encouraged, but only slightly.
spk_0
He's still terrified that another outbreak of the plague will erupt elsewhere in the city
spk_0
and overwhelm the already strained Marine Hospital Service.
spk_0
If that happens, Blue fears that he'll have no chance of containing the plague to San Francisco.
spk_0
It will spread beyond the city's limits. And Blue will become just the latest in a long line
spk_0
of federal doctors who failed to stop it.
spk_0
Wondery app, oh, whatever you get your podcast.
spk_0
From Wondery, I'm Lindsey Graham, and this is American Scam.
spk_0
The spring of 1903 marked a turning point in San Francisco's battle against bubonic plague.
spk_0
After almost three years of denial and obstruction, California's politicians,
spk_0
reporters, and businessmen finally came together to fight the disease spreading on the West Coast.
spk_0
This new era of cooperation gave Dr. Rupert Blue something he'd never had before in San Francisco,
spk_0
some time to think. So while sanitation teams did their work in Chinatown, Blue and his staff
spk_0
began looking into the question of exactly how bubonic plague was spread.
spk_0
Although it had been known for centuries that rats were carriers of the disease,
spk_0
little was understood about how it spread from animals to humans. Dr. Blue was about to get
spk_0
a lead on the mystery, but more people would have to die first. This is episode four, The Golden City.
spk_0
It's July 1903 in San Francisco's Chinatown. 35-year-old Italian laborer Pietro Spadaforea
spk_0
weaves his way through the crowds on his way home from work. Spadaforea doesn't live in Chinatown,
spk_0
but he's gotten into the habit of passing through to pick up cheap produce.
spk_0
And as he walks through the Mayas of Alleyways today, Spadaforea notices a change in the neighborhood.
spk_0
Many of the buildings have been partially torn down. Their balconies,
spk_0
stupes and awnings have been stripped away, leaving the streets feeling wider and more open.
spk_0
Then Spadaforea spots something on a street corner that makes them pause.
spk_0
It's a pile of discarded lumber just sitting out abandoned in the open.
spk_0
Spadaforea smiles because to him it's free firewood. He checks to make sure the coast is clear
spk_0
before helping himself to several planks. Oisting them onto his shoulder, he hurries off down
spk_0
an alleyway. Then he heads north before crossing Broadway into the Latin Quarter,
spk_0
home to the majority of San Francisco's Italian, Mexican and Spanish residents.
spk_0
His ragged leather shoes splash through puddles, tramping over discarded newspapers,
spk_0
bearing headlines about Dr. Rupert Blue and his campaign to rid Chinatown of rats.
spk_0
But Spadaforea doesn't read the newspapers and he doesn't concern himself with politics or public
spk_0
health. Like countless other poor immigrant laborers here, his every waking moment is devoted
spk_0
to scraping together a living to support his family. So when Spadaforea arrives at his
spk_0
tenement building, he carries the free firewood up the creaking staircase to the apartment he
spk_0
shares with his wife, mother and two small children. There Spadaforea breaks the planks into
spk_0
smaller pieces and then places a few inside their stove. Zoomed the dingy apartment is filled with
spk_0
warm, flickering light and the smell of hot food. But when Spadaforea lies down to sleep that night,
spk_0
he notices an itchy red bump on his arm. He scratches at it a few times and then drifts off happily
spk_0
to sleep. A few days later, Spadaforea comes down with a fever. Unable to report for work,
spk_0
he remains bedbound for several days as his condition steadily worsens. Eventually,
spk_0
his desperate family takes him to the Southern Pacific Hospital on Mission Street, but it's too late.
spk_0
On July 19th, 1903, Pietro Spadaforea succumbs to his sudden illness and by then his elderly mother
spk_0
is exhibiting the same symptoms and soon she too is dead. These fatalities are quickly reported
spk_0
to the Marine Hospital Service. Autopsies uncover tissue samples teeming with plague bacteria.
spk_0
At his headquarters in Chinatown, Dr. Rupert Blue reads the case reports with a growing sense of dread.
spk_0
The Latin Quarter is another densely populated district and if plague gains a foothold there,
spk_0
then a second outbreak in San Francisco is almost inevitable. So blue and his team trace Spadaforea
spk_0
movements. They soon find out about his habit of walking through Chinatown. That alone is unlikely
spk_0
to have exposed him to plague, but when health officers search the Deadman's property,
spk_0
they find the stolen firewood. This lumber must have been the source of the disease. Something
spk_0
about it killed Spadaforea and his mother. Blue soon discovers what it is, the wood is crawling
spk_0
with fleas. At this point in time, few scientists have made any connection between fleas and the
spk_0
spread of bubonic plague. The prevailing theory is that although rats can introduce the disease to
spk_0
a new place, it spreads primarily from person to person. But there are other theories. Four years
spk_0
ago, a French medical researcher began noticing insect bites on the bodies of plague victims in
spk_0
South Asia. He proposed that fleas, commonly found on rats, could transmit the disease to humans
spk_0
through their bites. But the international medical community dismissed the idea. They clung to
spk_0
the belief that plague primarily affected Asians due to their poverty and perceived poor hygiene.
spk_0
In the US, this racist theory was advanced by those at the very top of the medical profession,
spk_0
including surgeon general Walter Wyman himself. But after the deaths of Pietro Spadaforea and his
spk_0
mother, Dr. Rupert Blue begins to think that the flea hypothesis is correct. Spadaforea has no
spk_0
identifiable close contact with rats or anyone infected by the plague, but he has been exposed to
spk_0
fleas. Blue immediately orders all lumber removed from buildings in Chinatown to be disinfected
spk_0
before it's dumped. Then he concentrates the ongoing sanitation campaign on purging the city of
spk_0
rodents. He advocates the use of traps and poison, but also introduces a bounty of 10 cents for
spk_0
every rat dead or alive brought to his Chinatown laboratory. Their blues team of doctors carefully
spk_0
examine the rodents, searching for evidence of plague before incinerating the remains.
spk_0
The work is grim and painstaking, but as the pile of dead rats grows over the weeks that follow,
spk_0
the number of plague cases falls. Dr. Blue begins to feel cautiously optimistic.
spk_0
He may not only have ended the plague in California, but also finally confirmed how the terrible
spk_0
disease spreads. But by early the following year, that optimism looks suddenly premature.
spk_0
Mons after the death of Pietro Spadaforea, there's a new surge of cases in San Francisco's
spk_0
Latin Quarter. And as Dr. Blue pours over the data, a dreadful new possibility dawns on him.
spk_0
By focusing on rat control in Chinatown, he may have simply just driven the rodents out of one
spk_0
district and into another. It's February 1904 in a ramshackle rowhouse in the Latin Quarter.
spk_0
Inside a gloomy parlor, Giuseppe and Luisa Rossi are holding a funeral for their 18-year-old
spk_0
daughter, Irina. Candles flicker beside the open casket, throwing shadows on a crucifix on the
spk_0
wall, and a framed image of the Madonna. Dressed in black, Giuseppe gases down at his daughter's body
spk_0
and tugs at the beads of a rosary. Last week, Irana fell ill with a high fever.
spk_0
Giuseppe and Luisa could only wait and watch, bewildered and horrified as her daughter got sick
spk_0
or in sicker. She died earlier this morning. A knock at the door interrupts their silent vigil.
spk_0
Assuming it's the priest, Giuseppe goes to open the door, but it's not a clergyman waiting there.
spk_0
Instead, two federal health inspectors stand on the doorstep.
spk_0
They've received word that an Italian girl in the Latin Quarter has been bedbound with a high
spk_0
fever and they've come to investigate it as a possible case of plague. Giuseppe tells them that
spk_0
they're too late. Irana passed away this morning, but the officials aren't here to save her.
spk_0
They want to determine what killed her. Giuseppe recoils, refusing, asking the inspectors to leave and
spk_0
let them mourn their daughter in peace, but the officials stand their ground. They have a duty to
spk_0
investigate every suspicious death, and that means conducting an autopsy. After much debate,
spk_0
Giuseppe relents, but on two conditions. First, the autopsy must be done right away, so Irana can
spk_0
be buried tomorrow. Second, he demands to be present to ensure his daughter's body is treated with
spk_0
respect. After a short conference, the officials agree. So that night, Giuseppe sits in the marine
spk_0
hospital service laboratory in Chinatown, watching surgeons make careful incisions in Irana's body.
spk_0
Tears brim in his eyes as the doctors remove tissue samples from his daughter's lungs and spleen.
spk_0
And lab results soon confirm Irana died of pneumonic plague, the most aggressive form of the disease
spk_0
that attacks the lungs. So it comes as little surprise to the doctors when just days after her death,
spk_0
both Giuseppe and Luisa also succumb to the disease. For Dr. Rupert Blue, the death of the Rossi
spk_0
family is an alarming sign that plague is spreading once again. So immediately, he orders the sanitation
spk_0
efforts that prove so successful in Chinatown be extended to the Latin Quarter. The streets are
spk_0
then cleaned. Old and unhygienic structures are demolished, and concrete is laid in place of
spk_0
wooden floors, preventing rats from nesting underneath. These measures work. The rat population shrinks
spk_0
and the number of plague cases decline. A full-blown outbreak in the Latin Quarter has been averted.
spk_0
And by May of 1904, the citywide death rate has fallen by 15% on the previous year. Soon,
spk_0
there are weeks and then months with no new plague cases at all. Dr. Blue is hesitant to declare an
spk_0
end to the epidemic, but his boss in Washington has no such reservations. Confident and San Francisco
spk_0
is now safe, and the reputation of the Marine Hospital Service has been restored. Surgeon general
spk_0
Walter Wyman sends a telegram to Dr. Blue. His work in California is done. He's being reassigned
spk_0
again this time to Norfolk, Virginia. But unlike his unhappy predecessor Dr. Joseph Kinion,
spk_0
Blue leaves San Francisco a hero. His departure in early 1905 is marked with an official
spk_0
proclamation thanking him for his skillful cooperation in all pertaining to the welfare of San Francisco's
spk_0
sanitary health and commercial prosperity. After five years and at least 113 deaths, the plague
spk_0
seems to be over. The citizens of San Francisco begin to look to the future with hope. Their city has
spk_0
emerged from the crisis as a more modern metropolis, always to embrace the promise of the 20th century.
spk_0
Just over a year later, a few minutes after 5am on April 18th, 1906, San Francisco Mayor Eugene Schmitz
spk_0
is fast asleep in bed. When suddenly, he's woken by a violent tremor shaking the house.
spk_0
Julia? Julia? Wake up. What? What's going on? Think it must be an earthquake. Look at the ceiling.
spk_0
Above them, the chandelier swings back and forth wildly as the entire mansion trembles around them.
spk_0
Mrs. Schmitz bolts up in bed terrifying. Eugene, what do we do? I don't know. I don't know.
spk_0
But suddenly, just as quickly as it began, the shaking stops and the house falls silent.
spk_0
And the distance dogs begin to bark. Caulchously, Schmitz gets out of bed and pads over to the
spk_0
window. His wife draws up the covers around her. Is it over? Yes, my dear. I think it might.
spk_0
Schmitz is thrown to the ground as an even more powerful tremor rips up through the earth.
spk_0
He sprambles over to the bed as a spiderweb of crack splits the ceiling and chunks of plaster fall
spk_0
to the floor. He looks up at his wife, terrified in bed. We need to get out of the house. Come quickly,
spk_0
quickly. Schmitz grabs his wife's hand and they race downstairs in their nightclothes as their
spk_0
house continues to shudder around them. They bolt for the front door. They run out into the street
spk_0
away from the building that is now swaying violently on its foundations. When the air's wife is pale,
spk_0
she staggers and clutches onto her husband. Who's Eugene? How courage might you encourage? We're
spk_0
safe out here. We're safe. Let's just hold on. By the time the ground stops moving,
spk_0
more than 30,000 buildings in San Francisco have been reduced to rubble.
spk_0
Deep cracks have opened up in the cobblestone streets, swallowing entire houses,
spk_0
street cars and stage coaches and leaving more than 3,000 people dead.
spk_0
But the danger doesn't end with the earthquake. Over a quarter of a million residents will be left
spk_0
homeless by this disaster. And with all these people forced to live in filthy camps and shanty towns,
spk_0
disease will begin to spread among the ruins of San Francisco and the stage will be set for yet another
spk_0
battle with Ubonic plague. On Boxing Day 2018, 20-year-old Joy Morgan was last seen her church,
spk_0
Israel United in Christ or IUIC. I just went on my Snapchat and I just see her face
spk_0
lost in everywhere. This is the missing sister, the true story of a woman betrayed by those
spk_0
she trusted most. IUIC is my family and like the best family that I've ever had. But IUIC isn't
spk_0
like most churches. This is a devil that's cold. You know when you get that feeling right, you just
spk_0
I don't want to be here. I want to get out. It's like that feeling of I can't want to go ahead now.
spk_0
I'm Charlie Brent Coast Cough and after years of investigating Joy's case, I need to know
spk_0
what really happened to Joy. Binge all episodes of the missing sister exclusively and add free
spk_0
right now on Wondery Plus. Start your free trial of Wondery Plus on Spotify, Apple podcasts or in the
spk_0
Wondery app. You should man, they can and I'm here to bring you my new podcast, Nick can and
spk_0
I've heard y'all been using some advice in the love department. So who better to help than yours
spk_0
truly? Now I'm serious. Every week I'm bringing out some of my celebrity friends and the best
spk_0
experts in the business to answer your most intimate relationship questions. Having problems with
spk_0
your man, we got you. Catching feelings for your sneaky link, let's make sure it's the real deal
spk_0
first. Ready to bring toys into the bedroom? Let's talk about it. Consider this a non-judgment zone
spk_0
to ask your questions when it comes to sex and modern dating and relationships, friendships,
spk_0
situations and everything in between. It's gonna be sexy, freaky, messy and know what, you'll just have
spk_0
to watch this show. So don't be shy, join the conversation and head over to YouTube to watch Nick
spk_0
can in at night or subscribe on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcast. Want to watch
spk_0
episodes early in April? Join one to re-plus right now.
spk_0
Shortly after noon on April 18th, 1906, San Francisco Mayor Eugene Schmitz holds an emergency
spk_0
meeting in the rubble of City Hall. It's just a few hours since a devastating earthquake hit the
spk_0
city and Mayor Schmitz is concerned about law and order. He authorizes the police to shoot and kill
spk_0
any looters, but his city is facing far bigger problems than a few opportunistic thieves. In the wake
spk_0
of the earthquake, ruptured gas lines have sparked huge fires which are incinerating the few buildings
spk_0
left standing. By the end of the week, over 200,000 people are living in refugee camps in public
spk_0
parks. And soon these camps evolve into sprawling shanty towns. Crude wooden shelters line the dirt
spk_0
tracks at service streets, swarms of flies buzz around open air kitchens and poorly dug the trees,
spk_0
and as the weeks pass, the ground is churned into a swamp of mud, trash and human waste.
spk_0
Following the departure of Dr. Rupert Blue, sanitation measures in the city are left in the hands of
spk_0
military. Army medics try their best to organize waste disposal and impose some ordering the camps,
spk_0
but soon there are hordes of rats marauding the shanty towns, cases of pneumonia and dysentery are
spk_0
detected. And the fear is that more serious diseases won't be far behind. And in late spring 1907,
spk_0
more than a year after the earthquake, a young sailor is admitted to the US Marine Hospital with a
spk_0
high fever and swollen lumps on his groin. Soon he slips into a coma and dies. An autopsy confirms Dr.'s
spk_0
worst fears the bubonic plague has returned to San Francisco. More cases quickly follow culminating in
spk_0
six deaths in the span of less than a week. And after all the city has been through over recent years,
spk_0
the citizens of San Francisco are terrified. Luckily for them, there's been a change in leadership in
spk_0
the city. The plague skeptic Eugene Schmitz has been ousted in a corruption scandal. His political
spk_0
fixer A.Broof has gone to. And while Schmitz continues to protest his innocence, a new man has taken
spk_0
charge at City Hall. Unlike his predecessor, Mayor Edward Taylor has made public health a priority.
spk_0
So when the signs of another potential plague epidemic emerge, he wastes no time. Taylor immediately
spk_0
contacts Washington to request federal support. And Surgeon General Walter Wyman knows exactly who to send.
spk_0
Over the past four years, Dr. Rupert Blue has risen from obscurity to become one of the most
spk_0
celebrated doctors in the entire federal health service. Now the 39-year-old returns to the city
spk_0
where he made his name. When he arrives, he finds San Francisco on the brink of crisis yet again.
spk_0
There are still tens of thousands of people living in refugee camps and the city is scarred by burned
spk_0
out buildings, broken sewers and piles of rubble. The conditions are ripe for another epidemic.
spk_0
But Blue is determined that this time will be different.
spk_0
So in September of 1907, Rupert Blue attends a meeting of the San Francisco Board of Health.
spk_0
Room Falls silent as the Board's president rises to speak. Dr. Blue, I know I speak on behalf of
spk_0
everyone on this board when I say a hearty welcome back to San Francisco. Blue nods politely.
spk_0
Thank you. That's very kind of you all. This city has done much for me. I only wish I were back under
spk_0
better circumstances. As do we all, Dr. As do we all. Before we begin, let me say this plainly.
spk_0
The Board stands firmly behind a robust response to this outbreak. We offer you our complete support.
spk_0
There's a rumble of approval from around the table and then the president goes on.
spk_0
But I also must say that I hope we have all learned from the mistakes of the past.
spk_0
The last time we experienced such a dramatic surge in plague cases, your colleagues in the
spk_0
Federal Health Service pushed for well some extreme measures, measures which I believe frankly
spk_0
caused more harm than good. I assume you're referring to the quarantines of Chinatown.
spk_0
Yes, the quarantines, the travel bands, the forced inoculations. I know that was before your tenure.
spk_0
Still, memories are long and the damage lingers. Yes, I understand.
spk_0
I just don't want to cause undue alarm now. We can't afford a repeat of the public backlash we
spk_0
saw last time. Well, I'm in complete agreement. Of course, panic helps no one. But if we have the
spk_0
backing of the city and the state from the beginning, I'm confident quarantines and travel bands won't
spk_0
be necessary. The men on the board glanced at each other uncertainly and blew frowns. Well,
spk_0
gentlemen, is there something I should know? You just said I have your full support. And you do,
spk_0
you do. All of the men around this table are with you in spirit. In spirit. Well, Dr.
spk_0
Blue, the reality is the city is almost broke. The cost of reconstruction after the earthquake
spk_0
are endless. Our hands are tied not by a lack of will, but by the budget. Well, support in spirit
spk_0
won't stop an outbreak. I need an army. I need inspectors, sanitation crews, rap catchers,
spk_0
a city wide campaign, not any symbolic gesture. But we cannot afford it. Can you afford another
spk_0
quarantine? Another travel ban because without support, real support, gentlemen, gentlemen,
spk_0
there will be no alternative. You say you don't want these things, but they will be coming.
spk_0
The plague doesn't care about lines in the budget. And whatever the cost, it will be a fraction of
spk_0
what it will be later if we don't act now. Dr. Rupert Blue's warning hits home. And within days,
spk_0
San Francisco City Hall scraped together $20,000 a month to fund the plague eradication campaign.
spk_0
It's not as much as Blue wanted. On the streets of San Francisco, rats scurry over rubble and the
spk_0
sharp stench of rot and waste hangs in the air. So as Blue gets to work once again, he knows he's
spk_0
already running out of time. He quickly sets up a makeship headquarters and rented two-story house
spk_0
on Fillmore Street. It's a few miles west of downtown in one of the few areas spared by the earthquake.
spk_0
And from there, he and his team launched their new campaign against the plague.
spk_0
With the money from City Hall, Blue is able to employ 36 new health inspectors and he needs every
spk_0
single one of them. Cases are now surfacing all across San Francisco. So to manage the threat,
spk_0
Blue divides the city into 13 districts and dispatches teams of rat catchers to comb through each one.
spk_0
Soon piles of dead rats are accumulating at the Fillmore Street lab. Federal doctors dissect
spk_0
every specimen, checking for signs of plague in about 1.5% of the dead rodents test positive.
spk_0
Drawing on data from other epidemics, Blue knows that if rat infections hit 2%, the plague will
spk_0
rapidly spill over into the human population. And should that threshold be reached, the only option
spk_0
may be a quarantine of the entire city. But Blue does not have the resources to fight the epidemic
spk_0
and with the death toll rapidly rising for a time he sinks into despair. But then he realizes that
spk_0
there is an army out there that can help him. On that none of his predecessors have mobilized before,
spk_0
the people of San Francisco. Dr. Blue has learned that containing an outbreak of the plague
spk_0
requires more than just strict sanitary measures. It also demands careful public messaging.
spk_0
That was Dr. Joseph Kinion's primary mistake. His hardline tactics alienated people early on
spk_0
in the crisis and his standing in the city never recovered. But if Blue can make the people his
spk_0
allies and not his enemy, then he believes he still has a chance of saving San Francisco.
spk_0
He just has to find the right way to reach them. So on January 28th, 1908, Blue calls a public
spk_0
meeting at the merchant exchange building on California Street. More than 300 people pack the room
spk_0
representing nearly every sector of city life from business and trade union leaders to journalists
spk_0
and civic groups. Standing before the crowd Blue realizes he's nervous. He doesn't much like
spk_0
public speaking. But he fights off his nerves and takes to the stage. Then to utter silence in the room,
spk_0
he explains that San Francisco is currently losing its battle against bubonic plague. His rack
spk_0
catchers are killing over 13,000 rodents a week but their efforts seem to be having a little impact.
spk_0
The death toll from the latest outbreak is up to 74, making it officially the deadliest stretch of
spk_0
the entire plague crisis so far. And the number of infected rats is inching closer and closer to
spk_0
the critical 2% threshold. What's worse, soon it will be spring and rats and the deadly fleas they
spk_0
carry multiply even faster in warmer weather. They're a growing murmurs of dismay in the room at this
spk_0
news. But Dr. Blue doesn't try to reassure his audience. Instead he decides to raise the stakes even
spk_0
further. He reminds his audience that in just 4 months San Francisco will be under the national
spk_0
spotlight. In May 1908 a fleet of 16 U.S. Navy battleships is due to arrive in the city.
spk_0
Known as the Great White Fleet, this Armada has been dispatched on around the world trip by
spk_0
President Theodore Roosevelt to showcase America's growing naval power. San Francisco is the final stop
spk_0
on the first leg of the fleet's epic journey and a huge celebration is planned. A parade is
spk_0
expected to draw hundreds of thousands of people to the city in what will be a huge boost to its
spk_0
struggling economy. But if the plague epidemic means it's not safe for the Navy ships to dock in
spk_0
San Francisco then the celebration will be cancelled and held elsewhere. Everyone in the
spk_0
merchant exchange building knows exactly what a devastating blow that would be for the city.
spk_0
Blue can see it on every face in the room. But as he continues to speak he also senses a shift.
spk_0
Fear is being replaced by determination and by the end of the meeting Dr. Blue is convinced that
spk_0
he's found the army he needs. The Great White Fleet is coming and San Francisco will be ready.
spk_0
Hi I'm Denise Chan, host of Scam Factory. You might remember hearing about our investigative
spk_0
series that exposed what's really happening behind those suspicious texts you get. Inside heavily
spk_0
guarded compounds across Asia thousands are trapped in force to scam others or risk torture.
spk_0
One of our most powerful stories was jealous. A young woman who thought she'd found her dream job
spk_0
only to end up in prison in a scam compound. Her escape story caught the attention of criminals
spk_0
Phoebe Judge and am honored to share more details of jealous journey with their audience.
spk_0
But jealous story is just one piece of this investigation. In Scam Factory we reveal how a billion
spk_0
dollar criminal empire turns job seekers into prisoners and how the only way out is to scam your
spk_0
way out. Ready to uncover the full story? Binge all episodes of Scam Factory now. Listen to Scam
spk_0
Factory on the Wondering app or wherever you get your podcasts. In November 1974 IRA bombs
spk_0
through two Birmingham pubs killing 21 innocent people. Hundreds more rinsed. It was the worst attack on
spk_0
British soil since the Second World War. When a crime this appalling and shocking happens you
spk_0
want the police to act quickly and boy did they. The very next day they had six men in custody.
spk_0
Confessions followed and the men were sent down for life. Good riddance you might think except
spk_0
those men were innocent. Join me, Matt Ford and me, Alice Levine. For the latest series of British
spk_0
scandal all about the Birmingham six. It's the story of how a terrible tragedy morphed into a
spk_0
travesty of justice and how one man couldn't rest until he'd exposed the truth. Follow British
spk_0
and be sure to watch the show.
spk_0
By February of 1908 it seems that Dr. Rupert Blues Public Relations gamble has paid off.
spk_0
In the aftermath of the meeting at the merchant exchange building a group of San Francisco's
spk_0
biggest companies offered to help fund the cleanup of the city. Wells Fargo, the Southern Pacific
spk_0
Railroad and the Jeans manufacturer Levi Strauss all come together to raise a half million dollars
spk_0
for the Rad extermination campaign. A citizen's health committee is also formed and promptly purchases
spk_0
$15,000 worth of Rad traps and then promises a bounty of 25 cents for every dead Rad brought into
spk_0
its field offices. All around the city shows signs of a newfound commitment to cleanliness.
spk_0
Posters promoting public hygiene appear on bulletin boards and lampposts. Sanitation workers
spk_0
sweep the street and shopkeepers scrub their storefronts with new diligence. But for all these
spk_0
promising signs the situation remains perilous and Dr. Rupert Blues still wants more recruits for
spk_0
his civilian army to fight the plague. So he seeks out the one local institution whose influence
spk_0
rivals that of the press, the church. Just before Valentine's Day Dr. Blues steps inside the
spk_0
cool interior San Francisco's first unitarian church. He removes his boulder hat and walks down
spk_0
the aisle. A bearded priest and black robes is sweeping the floor and quietly blue asks for a word.
spk_0
The priest recognizes Dr. Blue from the newspaper and leads him into a small bare office.
spk_0
There, Blue sits down and explains the reason for his visit. A recent rise in infections among
spk_0
the city's rats has federal doctors worried. A 2% infection rate is the tipping point for an
spk_0
uncontrollable spread from rodents to humans and lab results suggest they've now potentially
spk_0
reached that threshold. The priest murmurs a quiet prayer. Dr. Blue reassures him that there is a
spk_0
chance that they've miscalculated. But to prevent the rate from climbing any higher, the city will
spk_0
need the help of every resident in the rat extermination effort. The priest listens closely, but then
spk_0
asks why Blue has come to him. Blue says that he wants to address the priest's congregation directly
spk_0
about pest control and sanitation. The priest strokes his wierry beard saying he understands Blue's
spk_0
urgency, but he's concerned about mixing public health with religious teaching. Blue nods,
spk_0
acknowledging the priest's concerns, but gently reminds him of the old Christian maxim,
spk_0
clandling this is next to godliness. Encouraging good sanitation is a moral responsibility,
spk_0
and only total community participation will see off the threat of this disease. Eventually,
spk_0
the priest agrees, and a few days later, on Valentine's Day, Dr. Blue shares his message with
spk_0
the congregation. But it's not just the first unitarian where his words are heard. Blue speaks
spk_0
with other religious leaders, and soon priests all across the city are echoing the rallying cry.
spk_0
So that as spring draws nearer, Blue can see the signs of progress everywhere. By April,
spk_0
he and his staff record a steep drop in rat infection rates, from 2% to 1.2%. It seemed at last the
spk_0
plague is in retreat, but it hasn't disappeared entirely. And with the arrival of the great white
spk_0
fleet just days away, Dr. Blue has a decision to make. He has the authority to close the port,
spk_0
with doing so with denies San Francisco its moment of redemption, its return to the national stage.
spk_0
Against his better judgment, he gives permission for the fleet to dock.
spk_0
And on May 6, 1908, Dr. Rupert Blue hurries along Fillmore Street toward his lab while all around
spk_0
him the city buzzes with excitement. Today is the day of the great white fleet's arrival.
spk_0
Children wave flags, vendors shout and red-white and blue-bunting flaps above their heads,
spk_0
but Blue weaves through the crowd with a not-in-a-stummy. He bustles up the steps of his lab when the door opens,
spk_0
and a group of his colleagues spill out, laughing and clapping each other on the back.
spk_0
One of them grins at Blue. Oh, morning, Dr. Blue. Good morning. Aren't you coming down to the
spk_0
Marina? They should be passing through the Golden Gate soon. No, no, no, I also can work to finish.
spk_0
You'll miss the fleet. No, no, that's all right. You go ahead, you've earned it.
spk_0
Someone's got to keep an eye on the rats, you know. Blue heads for the door, but the colleague steps
spk_0
away from the others and intercepts him before he goes inside. He speaks softly out of your shine.
spk_0
Dr. Is something wrong? I thought you'd be excited when you think where the city was six months ago.
spk_0
Yeah, I know. We've made great progress. I'm not ready to celebrate just yet.
spk_0
The numbers are improving, but the plague is not gone, and honestly, the thought of a million people
spk_0
crowding into the city makes me very uneasy. Well, then you should have called it off.
spk_0
Yes, and that's what's keeping me up at night. If there's a spike in infections,
spk_0
we'll all know who to blame. Dr. Blue, it's thanks to you that this city is even in a position to welcome
spk_0
the fleet. You really should come with us. You've earned it. I appreciate that, but no.
spk_0
All right. Well, I guess I'll see you tomorrow. Yeah, see you tomorrow.
spk_0
The colleague shrugs and walks off to join the others, leaving Dr. Blue alone on the steps.
spk_0
He adjusts his marine hospital service uniform and squares his shoulders and heads into the lab.
spk_0
As laughter and brass music drift faintly through the window, blue hunters over a dissecting tray in
spk_0
the lab. The stench of formaldehyde and decay fills the room, but Blue never looks up. He just keeps
spk_0
working and prays he's made the right decision. As elsewhere in the city, spectators line the waterfront
spk_0
in their thousands, waving flags and handkerchiefs. And as soldiers and sailors march through the wide
spk_0
avenues, the city bursts into celebration, a carnival of banners, music, and deafening applause.
spk_0
San Francisco feels reborn, proud, confident, and united.
spk_0
But for the three weeks that the great white fleet has docked in the city, Dr. Blue struggled to
spk_0
sleep. He tries to distract himself with the work, researching the physiology of fleas and how they
spk_0
spread the plague, but he can't focus. His thoughts keep returning to the sailors and
spk_0
enjoying their shoreleave after months at sea unwittingly spreading whatever infections they picked
spk_0
during their tour of the tropics. But then the three weeks comes to an end, and the great white fleet
spk_0
departs without a single reported new case of bubonic plague. And in the months the follow-in
spk_0
infection rates only continue to dwindle. In November of 1908, Surgeon General Walter Wyman officially
spk_0
declares San Francisco free of bubonic plague, and Dr. Blue and every member of his staff are presented
spk_0
with medals in front of a cheering crowd. A new chapter in the city's history can now begin,
spk_0
but the bubonic plague was not over. While Rupert Blue and his man had focused on
spk_0
killing rats in San Francisco, plague had spread into rural areas east of the city,
spk_0
and there the local squirrel population became infested with fleas, and despite attempts to eradicate
spk_0
the disease, the plague would lurk in the wooded hills of northern California for decades to come.
spk_0
By the time it next made the leap from animals to humans, Dr. Rupert Blue would be dead,
spk_0
and the responsibility for the nation's health would have passed to the hands of others.
spk_0
Following his triumphant departure from San Francisco, Dr. Blue lent his expertise to the battle
spk_0
against infectious disease in Hawaii and South America. And when Surgeon General Walter Wyman
spk_0
died suddenly in 1911, Dr. Blue was appointed as his successor. He went on to serve two terms as
spk_0
the foremost physician in America before he died in 1948 at the age of 79. Blue's predecessor in
spk_0
San Francisco, Dr. Joseph Kenyon, never fully recovered from his unhappy stint on the west coast.
spk_0
After leaving California under a cloud of controversy, Kenyon stepped away from public service.
spk_0
He returned to East and took a teaching role at George Washington University. It was a position
spk_0
he held until his death in 1919 at the age of just 58, his career having never reached the heights
spk_0
he had expected before his assignment to San Francisco. As for the bubonic plague in the United States,
spk_0
the story would resume in 2015 when a teenage boy returning from a camping trip in Yosemite
spk_0
National Park started scratching a tiny red bump on his leg. As the day went on, he developed a fever
spk_0
and body aches, prompting a visit to the hospital. The diagnosis shocked doctors there. It was
spk_0
bubonic plague again. Fortunately, with modern antibiotics, the boy recovered and much
spk_0
challenges changed since the plague first came to America. Over the past century, there have been
spk_0
countless medical breakthroughs. Sanitation has improved and doctors now have a far better understanding
spk_0
of how disease is spread. Yet some things remain the same, suspicion, and mistrust, prejudice,
spk_0
and misinformation. For all societies advances, there are some lessons that are still to be learned.
spk_0
From one rate, this is episode four of the plague in San Francisco for American Scandal.
spk_0
In our next episode, physician and historian Dr. Howard Marquell reflects on the legacy of the
spk_0
1900 San Francisco plague and how its lessons still echo in today's public health crises.
spk_0
If you're enjoying American Scandal, you can unlock exclusive seasons on Wondery Plus.
spk_0
Binge new seasons first and listen completely and free when you join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app,
spk_0
Apple Podcasts or Spotify. And before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a survey at
spk_0
Wondery.com slash survey.
spk_0
If you'd like to learn more about the plague in San Francisco, we recommend the books
spk_0
Black Death at the Golden Gate by David K. Randall, The Barbery Plague by Marilyn Chase,
spk_0
and The Plague and Fire by James C. Moore. This episode contains reenactments and dramatized details.
spk_0
And while in most cases we can't know exactly what this said, all our dramatizations are based on
spk_0
historical research. American Scandal is hosted, edited, and executed produced by me, Lindsey
spk_0
Granford Airship, audio editing by Trish and Paraga, sound design by Gabriel Gould, supervising
spk_0
sound designer Matthew Filler, music by Throne. This episode is written and researched by Joe
spk_0
Viner, fact checking by Alyssa Jung Perry, managing producer Emily Burke,
spk_0
development by Stephanie Jens, senior producer Andy Beckerman, executive producers,
spk_0
are William Simpson for Airship and Jenny Lauer department, Marshall Lewey, and Aaron O'Flairity for Wondery.
Topics Covered
American Scandal podcast
Dr. Rupert Blue
bubonic plague
San Francisco history
Chinatown sanitation campaign
public health
historical research
true events dramatization
Marine Hospital Service
disease outbreak
urban sanitation
plague transmission
flea hypothesis
rat control measures
early 1900s California