Jonathan Anderson's Dior Debut: The Response!

It's Thursday, October 2nd. Yesterday, Jonathan Anderson's first womenswear show for Dior walked in Paris. I'll do my recap and then I'll finish the show with other fashion news you need to know. Jonathan Anderson's Strange Dior Debut well, it happened. Jonathan Anderson showed his first Dior women's collection. His journey to this point has been long. Some, particularly those who hated his predecessor Maria Grazia Chiiri's collections might say arduous. It's it started in earnest, arguably in 2013 when he took over Loewe as creative director, making the label an IT brand, synonymous with an heirloom tomato that someone declared in a tweet to be so Loewe Anderson, quirky guy that he is, responded by making a purse that resembled that very tomato. Before that, he founded his namesake line, JW Anderson, which started with menswear in 2008 and moved into women's in 2010. That brand became synonymous with a pigeon purse. The rumors about Anderson going to Dior started in 2024. Oh, how the Internet loved those. The idea that Kiyori, whose commercial collections had become increasingly colorless and predictable over the course of her nearly decade long tenure at Dior, could be replaced by someone so whimsical and online was just delicious. And so Anderson's appointment and her ouster were formally announced around four months ago. We saw his menswear in July and now the women's collection has been unleashed like bursts of rainbow smoke at Becca Bloom's wedding. So after all that hope, all that hype, have his designs been the salve that haters of Kyrie's clothes have been longing for for years? The sweet relief from her beige Roman inspired gowns and insistence that all of it was a feminist statement? First, the Internet seemingly chased Virginie Viard out of Chanel, and then after enough complaining, Kiri was out too. So now that Anderson's in there like the people wanted, is fashion forever changed? Is everyone happy now? Well, not really. Boring.com posted to Instagram D by WTF was that Anderson is shockingly bad. Then again, Stylenotcom posted to Instagram yes to Dior women, exclamation point. Like Dario Vitale's debut collection for Versace, Anderson's Dior rebrand has been pretty polarizing. This was to be expected after we got a preview of his vision for women's Dior via red carpet dresses on a few actresses in recent months, A fiery disdain emerged online for some of the looks. There was Alba Roar, rocker at the Venice film festival in a navy gown that sort of made her look like she had an ottoman attached to her. But then there was Anya Taylor Joy in the ice blue dress with the sculptural woven hem at the Toronto International Film Festival, about which people had feelings. On the Dior Instagram feed, people commented, I don't hate it, I just don't like it. And give us back the Chiari, please. And it's not finished yet, right? Well, those feelings be damned, that same dress made three more appearances in Wednesday's show in black, beige and gray. Side note, great evening wear is becoming a surprisingly big trend this season. I'd argue Anderson's debut women's show was uneven. There were some strong looks. Whenever Anderson does something shrunken, people like it. Maybe because it looks cute and different in a moment when so many clothes are oversized. Like the bar jackets that carried over from his July men's show with contrasting black lapels, which he paired with pleated miniskirts. The miniskirts with the waist bows and floral prints. Some looked fuzzy, some looked stuffed. Also felt twee and different. The sculptural opening dress was, depending on how you feel about bows, inoffensive, arguably elegant, definitely quirky. I loved the tan suede hooded poncho coat toward the end, and I was relieved that, unlike many designers these days, he didn't just go look at a bunch of 80s stuff and try to recreate it. I should note that all of these looks would have been much more interesting if he showcased their beauty on diverse body types. There was also a lot of mid the dresses toward the end with the contrasting black ribbons that looked like they got drunk in the Chanel showroom and wandered off down the wrong Runway. The plain slim sweatpants that look like the stuff older rich ladies would thoughtlessly spend $3,300 on so they have something comfortable to wear on planes. That's a real price currently on Dior's website for sweatpants, by the way. They just seem out of place in a Runway show that had so many oddities in it. Looking at that stuff felt like going to the zoo and finding enclosures filled with house cats and squirrels instead of lions and tigers. Then there were some unappealing ideas. The sheer lace black dress with angular sleeves and cutouts over the armpits. Do people want to show off their armpits? The knit capes didn't look terribly special to me. Maybe those were more stately rich woman plain wear. And I don't even want to think about what Dior is going to charge for the denim miniskirts with the frayed hems that look like they could come from any store in the mall. But among the strangest looks were the dresses with the bulbous sculpture draping in front, which looked, particularly in videos, downright testicular. All that said, Anderson did two really smart things leading up to this debut. The first was to suggest that we probably wouldn't like his first shows all that much. Before his men's show, he told Women's Wear Daily, quote, you cannot rebuild a house in one show. It's impossible. You'd have to be like Christ, end quote. He added that he'd need five collections to, quote, break the cycle, end quote and fully establish his vision. This is also surely a useful message to impart to his sales hungry corporate overlords at lvmh. The second smart thing he did was to load the whole thing up with pretension. People eat that stuff up. There was the invitation, a porcelain plate affixed with porcelain nuts. I may be sensing a theme here. There was the viral video of him explaining the new logo, which now has three lowercase letters in a slightly different font. There were the show notes which read, According to Diana Sui, who reported this on her substack, daring to enter the house of Dior requires an empathy with its history, a willingness to decode its language, which is part of the collective imagination and the resoluteness to put all of it in a box. Not to erase it, but to store it, looking ahead, coming back to bits, traces or entire silhouettes from time to time. Like revisiting memories, it's an ever evolving sentiment and task that is both complex and instinctive. End quote. All right, sure. And let's not forget the whole introduction that people feverishly filmed for social media. It featured a video by documentary filmmaker Adam Curtis that Vogue reported was quote screen on a giant inverted pyramid and quote intercut horror movie clips with high speed flashes of footage of all the designers who preceded Anderson, like Yves St. Laurent, Marc Bohan, Gianfranco Ferre, John Galliano, etc. I'll hand it to Anderson. Honoring his predecessors including Maria Grazia, was a class act. I kicked off a thread in the Back Row chat to get a temperature read from the back row community about this show and the reactions were mixed but hopeful. Here are some other loose threads from around the fashion and culture Internet today. Have you seen the new Heider Ackerman show for Tom Ford? Photos didn't do the close justice in my opinion. You'll have to watch the video, although the soundtrack that The Tom Ford YouTube page posted was kind of terrible. So just mute that so many designers seem to be leaning into oddities and gimmicks, but this show felt like an old school showcase of just great clothes. Speaking of shows that were about the clothes instead of like endless Instagrams of invitations and whatever else, check out Lanvin and Dries Van Noten. Coparente is introducing athleisure that the business of fashion reports is quote infused with probiotics and prebiotics meant to transfer from fabrics to skin, end quote. This is part of the ongoing trend of companies trying to sell products that purport to take the effort out of wellness routines. Guess what? Copernic is calling this stuff Carewear. Finally, a couple of models in the Rabanne show wore sunglasses that looked like snorkel masks. Rabanne has a slow motion video of these on their site and they're kind of perfect. That's it for now. I'll see you next week with more fashion and culture news.

Jonathan Anderson's Dior Debut: The Response!

Interactive Transcript

Topics Covered

Jonathan Anderson's Dior Debut: The Response!

Interactive Transcript

Topics Covered

Related Episodes

212: How to manifest your dream home

Jessicas Food Reviews and Phone Check

Zac Young Serves Up Scares and Sweets on Halloween Baking Championship

What is Minecraft's Suspicious Stew?

Share Episode