Education
Episode 150: What the Funding Freeze Means for K-12 and Your Child
In Episode 150, Dr. Kim J. Fields discusses the implications of a recent funding freeze in K-12 education, which has significant consequences for students, especially those from marginalized communiti...
Episode 150: What the Funding Freeze Means for K-12 and Your Child
Education •
0:00 / 0:00
Interactive Transcript
spk_0
Have you had a chance to check out my interactive expert on my website?
spk_0
There are some great conversations and questions going on there.
spk_0
You can check it out at https colon-forward-slash-forward-slash-liberation-through-education.com-forward-slash-ask-me-anything.
spk_0
Welcome to another episode of K-12 Public Education Insights Empowering Parents of Colour.
spk_0
The podcast that converges at the intersection of educational research and parental actions.
spk_0
It's about making the trends, topics, and theories in public education understandable so that you can implement them into practical, actionable strategies that work for your children.
spk_0
My name is Dr. Kim J. Fields, former corporate manager, turned education researcher, and advocate.
spk_0
And I'm the host of this podcast.
spk_0
I got into this space after dealing with some frustrating interactions with school educators and administrators,
spk_0
as well as experiencing the microaggressions that I faced as an African-American mom raising my two kids who were in the public school system.
spk_0
I really wanted to understand how teachers were trained and what the research provided about the challenges of the public education system.
spk_0
Once I gained the information and the insights that I needed, I was then equipped to be able to successfully support my children in their educational progress.
spk_0
This battle-tested experience is what I provide as action steps for you to take.
spk_0
It's like enjoying a bowl of educational research with the sprinkling of mother-wit wisdom on top.
spk_0
If you're looking to find out more about the current information and issues in education that could affect you or your children, and the action steps you can take to give your children the advantages they need, then you're in the right place.
spk_0
Thanks for tuning in today.
spk_0
I know that staying informed about K-12 public education trends and topics is important to you, so keep listening.
spk_0
Give me 30 minutes or less, and I'll provide insights on the latest trends, issues, and topics pertaining to this constantly evolving K-12 public education environment.
spk_0
Earlier this year, President Trump froze more than $5 billion that's billion with the fee from the Department of Education.
spk_0
There are numerous implications of what this funding freeze could do to the Department of Education, including schools, black of trust, and the government, pending lawsuits, and the continued downslide of students.
spk_0
I think this doesn't affect you and your children and their local schools.
spk_0
Think again.
spk_0
I address what the implications of the funding freeze means to you as parents, with children in your local K-12 public schools, as well as other impacts at local level.
spk_0
Let's gain some insight on this.
spk_0
Sometimes you have to take what the President says with a grain of salt.
spk_0
Well, at least I do.
spk_0
After all the threats of withholding $5 billion in funding from the Department of Education, the Trump administration unfroze billions of K-12 education funds.
spk_0
The funds that were released from various grant programs to the states were for migrant education, teacher professional development, and teacher training, English learner services, academic enrichment programs, adult education programs, and adult literacy and civics education programs.
spk_0
Funds were also released for before and after school programs.
spk_0
The Education funds emphasize that states have to comply with a long list of federal civil rights laws.
spk_0
One casualty of the billions up to $6.8 billion of funding freeze that had taken effect and the funds are now released is that schools have a lack of trust in the government.
spk_0
Many education leaders say that the damage from the unexpected delays in funding restoration can't be easily undone and it created an environment in which trust can't be easily rebuilt.
spk_0
Most of the immediate impacts include employment positions that will remain unfilled.
spk_0
Beyond the immediate impacts, many school district leaders and others who work with them said that they are growing skeptical of depending on federal funding because they are unsure of the likelihood that it will happen again.
spk_0
While several urban school districts were able to move money around to support staff and programs for school districts that served smaller populations, a temporary loss of federal funding amounted to more than a minor blith.
spk_0
For example, some school programs were shut down in places like Allucia County, Florida, Badenow, North Dakota, and Grand Isle, Vermont.
spk_0
Classes for adult learners were suspended in Abilene, Texas, Fisherville, Virginia, and Oak Hill, West Virginia.
spk_0
And programs serving children of seasonal migrant workers in St. Louis and Warnatchee, Washington, suddenly could only serve a fraction of their typical student population.
spk_0
Additionally, the Cincinnati district had to halt plans to purchase new curriculum materials and the Fort Worth Texas district had to cancel contracts with local nonprofits.
spk_0
These are just a very small sampling of examples of the impact of a lack of funding on school districts across this country.
spk_0
Uncertainty was the primary effect of the funding freeze.
spk_0
Generally, school districts received 8-10% of their budgets from federal sources, the rest comes from state investments and local tax revenue.
spk_0
In the last 50 years, however, federal funding has largely been geared toward helping ensure high needs students, including those from low income families and those with disabilities, and making sure that they have access to the same income.
spk_0
And as you case, more opportunities as their peers.
spk_0
As a result of this, some states and districts depend on federal funding a lot more than others.
spk_0
And you can guess which school districts and states depend on federal funding based on the populations they serve.
spk_0
That's right, school districts with high concentrations of students of color and students from low income families who stand to lose several times more dollars per pupil than districts with low concentrations of these student populations.
spk_0
This affects more than 9,000 school districts across 46 states, according to federal spending data analysis.
spk_0
In real life, this looks like a loss of funding for after school programs and early childhood education programs for students of color and English language learners.
spk_0
It also looks like an interruption in services for students who qualify for special education. Are you seeing a pattern here?
spk_0
Federal funding makes up more than 10% of annual revenue for approximately 25% of this nation's 13,000 public school districts.
spk_0
At the state level, public schools, dependents on federal funding ranges from nearly 19% in Arizona and New Mexico to less than 6% in Connecticut and New Jersey.
spk_0
Simply stated, this means that more money equals more resources.
spk_0
Less money equals less resources.
spk_0
It's important to remember that these federal funds don't just go to public schools.
spk_0
The federal government requires that public school districts ensure non-public school students receive equitable services and this includes private schools which benefit from a portion of the allocation from these federal funds.
spk_0
For private schools that have smaller enrollments, they need federal funds to add professional development for teachers as one type of funding that's necessary for the school.
spk_0
You should also be aware that many state education agencies receive a large amount of their annual funding from the federal government.
spk_0
Even with a disbanded department of education, state education agencies need federal funds to provide high quality services to the school districts they serve.
spk_0
The Trump administration emphasizes shifting federal education responsibility to the states.
spk_0
But without federal funding, it's like telling the states, good luck. You're on your own.
spk_0
The bottom line is that without the funding, fewer education services will be provided.
spk_0
Hey, it's Dr. Kim Fields.
spk_0
And I want to hear from you. Has a recent interaction at your child's school left you feeling frustrated, exasperated, or even angry?
spk_0
Send me an email at Kim at LiberationThroughEducation.com describing your situation, whether it was about an academic struggle, a disciplinary challenge, peer pressure, bullying, or some other situation.
spk_0
Once reviewed, I'll highlight your situation and provide my feedback on air in an upcoming episode.
spk_0
I can't wait to hear from you. Again, that email is Kim at LiberationThroughEducation.com.
spk_0
Not surprisingly, two dozen states have sued President Trump over the $6.8 billion dollar school funding freeze because they say that the move was unconstitutional.
spk_0
The lawsuit filed July 4th of this year in the U.S. District Court of Rhode Island characterized the Trump administration's unprecedented withholding of billions of dollars that Congress appropriated for education as a brazen attack on the constitutional separation of powers.
spk_0
The lawsuit also contended that federal laws were violated, especially those governing education programming, administrative procedures, and executive branch spending of funds allocated by Congress.
spk_0
The lawsuit seeks to restore all the federal funding cuts that were made from schools in the states listed as plaintiffs in the lawsuit.
spk_0
Are you ready to know whether your state was one of the plaintiffs in this lawsuit? Then listen up.
spk_0
Those states seeking relief on behalf of their schools include Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oregon,
spk_0
Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, and Wisconsin. The District of Columbia is also a plaintiff.
spk_0
There's been no update on the status of this lawsuit to date.
spk_0
So the $6.8 billion in federal funds has been reinstated. The programs, the curriculum, the staff needed to provide enriching educational experiences for all children seems to be stable for the moment.
spk_0
Schools have always managed to secure funding. However, funding has not always translated into increased test scores.
spk_0
The question is, why aren't scores still following on the nation's report card and why are high school seniors still following further behind?
spk_0
If money is not the reason, then what is? The National Assessment of Educational Progress is known as NAIT or the Nation's Report Card.
spk_0
It displays how well this country's students are doing academically, with test results given to Ford and eighth graders every two years.
spk_0
It's designed to tell us what's happening to student achievement, but not why student achievement continues to fall.
spk_0
Science scores for eighth graders are down since 2019, which was the last time students were tested in that subject.
spk_0
High school seniors have also lost ground in reading and math.
spk_0
12th grade reading scores hit a peak in 2009 and failed significantly over the following 10 years.
spk_0
12th grade math scores peaked in 2013 and have also fallen since 2019.
spk_0
Results released in September of this year from the 2024 Nation's Report Card show that more students than ever before are scoring below NAIT's threshold for mastery of basic skills.
spk_0
This is the first time the test has been given to 12th graders since before the pandemic.
spk_0
Overall, 12th graders who took the test in 2024 were less prepared for college than their peers in 2019.
spk_0
This means that high school students are taking their next steps in life with fewer skills and less knowledge in core subject areas compared to their predecessors
spk_0
a decade ago, which to me is a dangerous trend for the overall subject area knowledge and critical thinking skills necessary to make informed decisions in the future in this society.
spk_0
The gap between the lowest performing and highest performing students is now widening across all subjects and grades, highlighting the stark reality that schools today are equipping only some students for post-secondary success.
spk_0
Money and decline in student achievement pre-pandemic are not the cause for the current woes in academic achievement.
spk_0
What seems to be the main culprit is the rise of smart phones and in particular the advent of social media platforms targeting young people.
spk_0
Phones distract students from math homework just as much as they do from reading.
spk_0
Because students are not taught how to discern factual information from opinion online, the readings that most students do is superficial.
spk_0
Surveys indicate that disadvantaged students spend the most time on their devices while motivated students of all backgrounds may be able to use them to enhance their skills.
spk_0
While there may not be a definitive causal link between smart phones and learning, the circumstantial evidence is sufficiently strong.
spk_0
It may be worth looking back into the past when elected officials from both political parties came together around one agenda grounded in articulating clear standards for student learning and holding schools accountable for ensuring students met the potential to be able to be more accurate.
spk_0
As well as those standards on state tests, this later became known in 2002 as the no child left behind act or nickel beam.
spk_0
This law produced results in reading and math such as steadily rising levels of achievement driven by unusually large gains for low performers, precisely the opposite of the pattern over the last decade.
spk_0
The downside to that law was that it didn't emphasize other subjects such as civics, history, and science instruction.
spk_0
Another downside that I saw to these standards for state testing was that teachers began teaching to the test instead of teaching students how to think and how to learn.
spk_0
A loosening of that law's provisions began around 2011 and may be a contributing factor to the recent backsliding in student academic achievement.
spk_0
Worth noting is that at the high school level, girls scores declined further than boys scores in science, reopening a gender achievement gap in that subject that had been closed by 2019.
spk_0
A possible reason for the girls scored decline is that some of the initiatives that schools had in place to encourage girls in STEM were lost in the shuffle of pandemic era learning because when the education system was disrupted, some of the extra things that teachers might have been doing like having role models come in or having days focused on technical careers.
spk_0
Let's tie all of this information back to the funding discussion.
spk_0
The NAEP results come as operations at the National Center for Education Statistics, which is the federal statistical agency responsible for collecting, analyzing, and reporting data on the condition of US education from early childhood to adult education.
spk_0
And its parent organization, the Institute for Education Sciences, face uncertainty following federal staffing cuts at the US Department of Education early this year following these widespread reductions in force, representatives from the National Assessment governing board, the organization that sets policy for NAEP, announced that some tests were done by the federal government.
spk_0
The NAEP results will shrink in scope over the next 10 years, although the main reading and math tests in 4th and 8th grades, which are required by law, will continue as scheduled.
spk_0
These latest test results from the 2024 Nation Report Card, throw into sharp focus how critical it is to have the test, which is the only nationally comparable assessment of student abilities on this scale for identifying persistent trends in student achievement.
spk_0
So what can you do with the information that I've just shared? Here are the action steps you can take regarding how funding for the K-12 public education system impacts you locally.
spk_0
In order to reverse the trends in lower academic achievement, it's important that you continue reinforcing and enhancing what your children learn in school.
spk_0
The fact is that higher achieving students are coming into schools and tests with more experience seeing science, for example, and doing science at home.
spk_0
The research indicates that if you have more science starting in pre-K and kindergarten, it engages students, it increases their interest in school, and it increases their math and literacy performance.
spk_0
A great science kit for young learners, those between the ages of 6 and 8 years old, comes from national geographic, including kits that contain 15, 45, and up to 100 experiments.
spk_0
These are great ways for kids to incorporate STEM projects at home. Also, keep reading to your child every day, and when they're old enough to read by themselves, provide resources, and the designated space for them in the practice they're reading skills daily.
spk_0
And because reading requires a lot of coordination, mentally, and physically, the optimal allow-it-time to practice reading is only 20 minutes per day, every day.
spk_0
A series of books that I enjoyed and were very effective for teaching my children to learn to read was a pig, Ken Jig, reading series, starting at around age 5.
spk_0
I also like the Montessori phonetic reading blocks for children to start recognizing and sounding letters as early as age 3.
spk_0
Additionally, include mathematics practice, even with your preschooler and kindergarten as part of your at-home work.
spk_0
Research indicates that improving math skills also improves reading and literacy skills.
spk_0
The Scholaristic series of math games and the Kugin spelled COOGAN math games have been a hit with my grandchildren in teaching them mathematics concepts.
spk_0
By the way, I devoted an entire episode to the importance of early math literacy skills in episode 61.
spk_0
The main thing about incorporating learning at home is giving it fun so kids don't even realize that they're learning.
spk_0
Here, of this episode, takeaways.
spk_0
The funds that were released from various grant programs to the states were for migrant education, teacher professional development and teacher training, English learner services, academic enrichment programs, adult education programs, and adult literacy and civics education programs.
spk_0
Funds were also released before school and after school programs.
spk_0
One casualty of the billions of dollars that were frozen that would be up to $6.8 billion is that it created a lack of trust in the government by the schools.
spk_0
Many education leaders said that the damage from the unexpected delays in funding restoration cannot be easily undone and it created an environment in which trust can't easily be rebuilt.
spk_0
Schools have always managed to secure funding. However, the funding is not translating into increased test scores.
spk_0
Results released in September of this year from the 2024 Nation's report card showed that more students than ever before are scoring below names threshold from mastery of basic skills.
spk_0
It's the first time the test has been given to 12 graders since before the pandemic.
spk_0
Overall, 12 graders who took the test in 2024 were less prepared for college than their 2019 peers.
spk_0
This means that high school seniors are taking their next steps in life with fewer skills and less knowledge in core subject areas compared to their predecessors a decade ago.
spk_0
These latest test results from the 2024 Nation's report card froze into sharp focus how critical it is to have the test, which is the only nationally comparable assessment of student abilities on this scale for identifying persistent trends in student achievement.
spk_0
Tying all of this information back to the funding discussion has these implications.
spk_0
The NAEP results come as operations at the National Center for Education Statistics and its parent organization, the Institute for Education Sciences, faced uncertainty following federal staffing cuts at the U.S. Department of Education earlier this year.
spk_0
What are your thoughts about the defunding and refunding of buildings of dollars to work, education department and its impact on your local school?
spk_0
Let me know your thoughts or experiences by leaving me a text comment on my podcast website, www.haitweilgeeducationinsights.blessedbrow.com
spk_0
Here's how you can leave a text comment, go to the episode description page and click on the send me a text message link.
spk_0
Again, it's k12educationinsights.blessedbrow.com. If you enjoyed this episode, why not listen to another episode from my library?
spk_0
It could take us a little at a 15 minutes of your day. And remember, new episodes come out every Tuesday.
spk_0
And before I forget, would you do me a favor, go online right now and share this episode with one friend who you think will love it.
spk_0
Thanks for listening today. Be sure to come back for more insights on k12educationinacopits that impact you and your students.
spk_0
Until next time, A to learn something new every day.
spk_0
If you choose to subscribe, I'll give you a special shout out thanking you in an upcoming episode.
spk_0
Remember, that's HTTPS, Colton, forward slash, forward slash, tinyurl.com, forward slash, podcast support, to subscribe.